Talk:Area 88

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

	Area 88 is within the scope of WikiProject Anime and manga, which aims to improve Wikipedia's coverage of anime and manga. If you would like to participate, you can edit this article or visit the project page (Talk). See our portal to learn more.
B	This article has been rated as B-Class on the assessment scale.

Contents 1 DVD release of original OVA by ADV 2 Aircraft section 2.1 Alternative 1: detailed summary 2.2 Alternative 2: wikitable 3 Characters 4 sound tracks 5 suggestion 6 Article Cleanup Co-Ordination Point 6.1 Discussion

[edit] DVD release of original OVA by ADV

"Central Park Media would later let the original OAV license lapse, which allowed ADV Films to release it on an undisclosed date in 2006."

What's the source for that? -CWD 04:22, 20 April 2006 (UTC)

I believe that ADV Films is releasing each episode for $5 on their website. Kschang77 23:50, 3 December 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Aircraft section

There's nothing wrong with the information here but I think it could benefit by being written as a encyclopedic summary rather than a big, long list. I understand that it would be difficult to do without being repetitive, i.e. "so and so flew this, so and so flew that, etc." but I'm sure somebody with enough knowledge and interest (obviously, some of you do) could pull it off. Elvrum 00:03, 24 May 2006 (UTC)

Formatting question: Should it be split into gov./rebel/other sections, or left as an alphabetical list? I think splitting it up would make things a little easier to read. Virogtheconq 21:13, 30 May 2006 (UTC)

Splitting the list shouldn't be necessary. In fact, there was already a "rebels" section, but I combined it with the longer list because there were redundant entries (jets flown by both forces) between the two sections. Also, there were jets flown exclusively by rebels in the main section, so they were inconsistent. Since it is an aircraft section, I think it should focus on aircraft first, pilots second, so as far as lists go, alphabetical would probably be best. If you want something easier to read however, I could propose a table. Elvrum 22:19, 30 May 2006 (UTC)

I like the wikitable idea, but that's because I've worked with them before to improve other lists. The story section, while not a bad idea, might be a bit hard to use since the article shouldn't contain an in-depth story summary of A88. As far as the table structure goes, your version isn't bad, though I would suggest perhaps we could change pilots to "Notable pilots", with "notable" criteria meaning appearing in more than one mission (manga) or episode (OVA, series). Otherwise, the entry would just be blank and/or leave a note regarding which side it was used by - it'd cut down on the vertical size of the table. Virogtheconq

You're right: too much detail for alt. 1. I wouldn't mind changing "pilots" to "notable pilots," but you bring up an interesting point: should that same criteria be applied to the aircraft, i.e. notable aircraft only? Either way, we shouldn't quite delete anything just yet. Let's compile as much information as we can and see what can be trimmed out later. One more thing: do you think detailing the exact mission/act/episode is too much? Personally, I think it makes the list more useful, but it's probably not necessary. Elvrum 01:53, 31 May 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Alternative 1: detailed summary

I think the aircraft section could benefit from a detailed summary as opposed to a list. The problem with this is it could get very redundant, i.e. repeating story details already mentioned in the story summary. Because of that, I think that aircraft info could be detailed in the story section. For example:

In his early days at flight school, Shin flew a Cessna 150. At Area 88, he initially flew an F-8E Crusader. Shin's ally Boris also flew a Crusader, and because of the its capability to fly with its wings folded, they were able to squeeze through the narrow holes of a metal barrier called a "fang." Upon totaling his Crusader, Shin borrowed Saki's F-15 Eagle until purchasing his own F-20 Tigershark. Etc., etc., etc..

Elvrum 23:14, 30 May 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Alternative 2: wikitable

Here's one possiblity. This would need to be cleaned up big time, but it could work. However, I would still like to explore some other possiblities. Elvrum 23:14, 30 May 2006 (UTC)

A wikitable sounds better. Most people would understand. 70.68.46.180 06:17, 22 June 2006 (UTC)

Aircraft	Pilot(s)	Source
		Manga (Mission)	OVA (Act)	TV (Episode)
A-4F Skyhawk	Greg Gates, Leon, Randy, Campbell, and anonymous rebel pilots		?	?
A-10A Thunderbolt II	Greg Gates		1-3
Blackburn Buccaneer	Roundell			?
Dassault Mirage F-1	Kitori Palvanaff and anonymous rebel pilots			?
English Electric Lightning	Escape Killers	10	1–2
F-4J/E Phantom II	Shin Kazama, Mickey Simon, Bugsy, and anonymous rebel pilots		?
	Patrick Reed, Claus and Palof			?
F-5E Tiger II	Shin Kazama and an anonymous pilot	5–10	2
F-8E Crusader	Shin Kazama and Boris	1–3	1
F-14A Tomcat modified for single-pilot operation	Mickey Simon	1–	1–3
F-15 Eagle	Shin Kazama and Saki	4
F-16A Fighting Falcon	Invulnerable Charlie		?
F-20 Tigershark	Shin Kazama		3
F-105D Thunderchief	Nguyen Van Com		?
F-100 Super Sabre	Mickey Simon		?
F/A-18A Hornet	Anonymous pilots		?
IAI Kfir	Saki, Jess, and anonymous pilots		?
J35F Draken	Anonymous pilots			?
MiG-17 Fresco	Anonymous rebel pilots
MiG-21 Fishbed	Anonymous rebel pilots
MiG-23 Flogger	Patrick Reed and anonymous rebel pilots			?
MiG-27D Flogger	Wolfpack		?
Sea Harrier FRS Mk.1	Anonymous rebel pilots (OVA) and Kim Aoba (TV series)		?	?
T-6 Texan	Morris	4	-

id suggest the table and include how it used and such as the copters are used for resue missions or to transport personnel and the Ch-130 herkules planes for fuel, missile, and other such supply work

[edit] Characters

The list of characters is getting rather long. I suggest moving all the character descriptions to a separate List of Area 88 characters article, so the main A88 article doesn't have this ginormous section that's really not worth much in it.Virogtheconq 18:30, 26 July 2006 (UTC)

[edit] sound tracks

re the dases for the Soundtracks Japanese or us relesed time?

[edit] suggestion

i think we can remove some pilots that have first name only or no importance to the story really( like campbell). or terms like unknown pilots since we dont know who pilots em' why place that in? --Spartan117009 00:34, 12 November 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Article Cleanup Co-Ordination Point

i think i'll just start ahead--Spartan117009 01:50, 14 December 2006 (UTC)