Talk:Thor's Chariot
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
This article is part of WikiProject Stargate, an attempt to build a comprehensive and detailed guide to Stargate on Wikipedia. |
 |
[edit] Protected Planets Treaty
This planet is obviously under the Protected Planets Treaty. Why then did Heru-ur attack the planet? Even though the hammer wasn't operational, the fact that the planet was protected under the treaty should have disuaded him.
Though forbidden, it's clear that the Goa'uld are willing to attack a protected planet if they feel they can get away with it. The Tollan are instructed to send warheads to Earth, the Goa'uld launch an asteroid at the planet, etc. With the destruction of the Hammer, pretty much the only Asgard technology on the planet that is accesible to the natives, perhaps he felt there was no way for the Asgard to learn of the attack.
- In Red Sky (Stargate SG-1), Teal'C observes that there is no Thor's Hammer on the planet they've just arrived to. Daniel then points out that they wouldn't need one if they were in the Protected Planets Treaty. This suggests that Cimmeria is in fact not in the Protected Planets Treaty.
- Regarding your other points - I think you should rewatch Fail Safe (Stargate SG-1). In it, O'neill notes that the Goa'uld (or rather, Annubis) instructed the Tollan to send warheads to Earth. Freyr responds by saying that the Goa'uld denied responsibility. And since I don't think they even know about Annubis, yet, I'd say that the Goa'uld were probably being sincere.
- Also, shortly after Fail Safe, Earth does get Asgard technology... TerraFrost 05:55, 10 July 2006 (UTC)
[edit] removed from parent article
I've removed the following from the article:
| “ | Plotholes. When SGC realise that Cimmeria is under attack they debate whether to intervene and provide aid. SGC KNOW that these people are or at least were protected by the Asgaard, the friendly aliens that SGC want to contact. What is the debate? If the Asgaard found out that SGC had destroyed the Hammer and then refused to help when the Goa'uld attack then how friendly could they be? After all in In the Line of Duty (Stargate SG-1) SGC aid the Nasyans without any debate at all. Why aren't SGC going in with all guns blazing instead of reluctantly letting SG-1 go in alone? | ” |
Although the point is fair, imho, it's not very encyclopedic. TerraFrost 05:36, 10 July 2006 (UTC)
