Talk:Duchy of Saxony
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
|
[edit] Merge suggestion discussion from 20 March 2006
- Could this article become part of a new history of lower saxony? feb2006
—The preceding unsigned comment was added by Foundert (talk • contribs) 20:23, 26 February 2006. re:user talk: Foundert
re: User:Petri Krohn placed Mergetags: ({{mergefrom|Old Saxony}}) 12:14, 20 March 2006, user Talk: Petri Krohn
No Merge— expand! Historically based articles like this should never be merged together, each has it's own independent context and corpus of literature, public, private, and archival that refers to it within the context of the times. Moreover, the geographic boundaries rarely if ever line up with such successor states, and only when they do should a merge be seriously entertained, but that then orphans the title plus the place in it's times, and buries the context of same trivializing it within the greater article obfusticating understanding by people that run across these terms in references—which is why they (our customers) are looking for more information herein! Q.E.D. FrankB 22:25, 15 May 2006 (UTC)
I'm not sure what should be merged where, but it seems there are too many articles here. Saxons, Old Saxony, and Duchy of Saxony have significant overlap. Of the three, Old Saxony is the term with the least well-defined meaning, so it should probably be the one to go. I agree that a History of Lower Saxony article that spans two millennia would be misleading; Lower Saxony is a different entity today than Old Saxony/Saxony was in Iron Age or Medieval times. Chl 15:59, 20 May 2006 (UTC)
Well, Old Saxony is very important to look at if one is trying to understand things like the origins of the Anglo-Saxon conquest of Britian. The modern province of Saxony is an entirely different area, and is nearly irrelevent to the history of Old Saxony, thus complicating searches. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 12.214.2.219 (talk • contribs) 27 May 2006.
- True, but can't this be covered at, let's say, Saxons? Then Old Saxony could be a redirect there. I guess the question is if there is anything to say about Old Saxony besides that it is the original territory of the Saxons. Chl 16:57, 27 May 2006 (UTC)
