User talk:WikiMan53/Editor review/archive2
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
< User talk:WikiMan53 | Editor review
[edit] WikiMan52
WikiMan53 (talk • contribs) I have been on Wikipedia for a while now and want to know how to improve myself. WikiMan53 T/C e@ edits 21:27, 28 January 2007 (UTC)
Reviews
- I don't see a lot of mainspace edits here, and if they are, they're a bunch of small edits. Edits like this show a general lack of understanding policy (rvv = reverting VANDALISM!) as does the next one showing you attempting to protect a page. Alarming on this page is a series of 13 edits, all removing valid redlinks. In fact, I don't see very many mainspace edits that is not removing a redlink - please review WP:RED. --Wooty Woot? contribs 08:06, 9 February 2007 (UTC)
- I'm still thinking about the VandalProof mess. You have told an user that his VP request has been rejected [1], removed it from the VP Approval list [2] and then removed any evidence about this by cleaning the talk page of another user [3].
- While checking with mathbot's tool, apart for the double 100%, I have noticed that this user flagged only 11 contribution as minor. Since you had done previously counter-vandalism, red link removal and so on, I'm pretty sure that his understanding of Help:Minor_edit#When_to_mark_an_edit_as_minor is not so good.
- I think that what you need to improve is a better understanding of WP policies.
- Page moves like this [4] show a lack of understanding of Wikipedia's naming policies. When I moved it back, I left a pretty clear edit summary (see Central High School disambiguation page) that I felt explained why it was a bad move. I found your subsequent move, and edit summary [5] to be even more troubling. While enthusiasm is great, it concerns me that you jump into new things (like page moves) without really understanding all the implications. You should study how things are done closely before you attempt large scale changes. Dina 12:28, 11 February 2007 (UTC)
Comments
- View this user's edit count using Interiot's 'Wannabe Kate' Tool and his edit summary usage using mathbot's tool.
Questions
- Of your contributions to Wikipedia, are there any about which you are particularly pleased, and why?
- Well, I like to clean up vandalism and fix links, I wouldn't say I'm pround of any ONE, I'm just happy to help a wonderful community
- Have you been in any conflicts over editing in the past or do you feel other users have caused you stress? How have you dealt with it and how will you deal with it in the future?
- I have been in a few, I hate when people just delete what I say, but I just go around it by waiting, then posting and making sure to say (Conflict) at the end.
Question for Reviewer:
-
- At this time would you say Support if I ran for admin? Why or why not?
