[edit] Accessories
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
NES Zapper |
Mid |
Zapper gun released with the Nintendo Entertainment System in 1985 for use with their games. |
Stub |
|
[edit] Consoles
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
3DO Interactive Multiplayer |
Low |
|
Start |
|
Amiga |
Mid |
Popular computer in the 1980s and 90s, ahead of its time in terms of graphics and sound quality. |
Start |
Too much trivia, lacking in refs. |
Amstrad Mega PC |
Low |
Amstrad's version of Sega's TeraDrive. |
Start |
Article covering mainly the unit's specification but lacking detail in other areas such as market impact. |
Apple II series |
High |
One of the most popular computer gaming platforms. |
A |
One of the most popular and important gamin platforms of the 1980s. |
Atari 2600 |
High |
|
B |
refs, obviously. A fairly good history, specs are fine, but little else. |
ColecoVision |
Low |
|
Start |
Significantly smaller than surrounding articles. Refs. |
Commodore 64 |
Mid |
|
FA |
|
Game Boy |
High |
Nintendo's most successful console |
Start |
Needs to be expanded. |
Game Boy Advance |
Low |
Part of the Game Boy line |
Start |
Lead, refs. Jumps directly into the hardware, not much else. |
Game Boy Advance SP |
Low |
Part of the Game Boy line |
Start |
Mostly a list of changes and a ton of unsourced criticisms. |
Game Boy Color |
Low |
Part of the Game Boy line |
Start |
No sources, short (one paragraph) sections. |
Game Boy line |
High |
The dominant handheld console since '89. |
B |
Covers nearly all Nintendo handhelds, briefly. |
Game Boy Micro |
Low |
Part of the Game Boy line |
B |
Only two references in the "reaction" section. |
Handheld electronic game |
Mid |
|
Start |
Intellivision |
Low |
|
B |
No refs, could stand to be reorganized (History, features, peripherals, specs?). Image:Intellivision.jpg should be replaceable. |
Nintendo 64 |
High |
|
B |
Inline references and coherency: list of "notable" games? Technical specs right in the middle? |
Nintendo DS |
Mid |
|
GA |
|
Nintendo Entertainment System |
High |
|
FA |
|
Nintendo GameCube |
Mid |
|
B |
References. Not outstanding by any means. Promo images might be replace with free photos. |
PlayStation |
High |
Most important console of its era, first popular console with CD media. |
B |
Needs references. Lots of references. |
PlayStation 2 |
High |
|
B |
Jumps into "history" with little context. Convert links to references, but needs more refs anyway. Not bad but not excellent. |
PlayStation 3 |
Low |
Not released as yet. |
B |
Ineligible for GA status until it is released and stable. |
PlayStation Portable |
Low |
|
GA |
Lead needs expansion. Plenty of technical info, if that's your thing. |
Sega Dreamcast |
Low |
|
B |
Refs. |
Sega Master System |
High |
SMS and NES were the two most important consols of their era; head-to-head combattants. |
B |
Needs refs and free images. |
Sega Mega Drive
(aka Sega Genesis) |
High |
|
B |
Refs, obviously, and once you get past the history there's a lot of bulleted lists. Promo images ought to be replaced. |
Sega Saturn |
Mid |
|
B |
Refs, especially for comparisons to PSX versions. No pic of the "standard" controller. |
Sega TeraDrive |
Low |
Sega's unsucessful attempt at creating a Mega Drive/PC combo for the Japanese market. |
Start |
Fair amount of info on specification and brief mention of SDK, but lacking much else. |
Super Nintendo Entertainment System |
High |
|
B |
Needs (inline) references badly (Yakuza? Blue-collar anti-Japanese sentiment? WTF?) |
Wii |
High |
Current-gen console. Cutting-edge motion sensing technology. |
GA |
Need some rewriting |
Xbox |
Mid |
|
B |
Standardize refs. Seems like there's a tone issue, although it's only slightly more prominent here than in other articles here. Needs more pictures (including one of the original controlller). |
Xbox 360 |
Mid |
|
GA |
Needs reorganized, mostly. See: Peer Review |
ZX Spectrum |
Mid |
One of the more popular line of computers in the 1980s in Europe. Important for the British computer games industry. |
A |
Mostly complete and stable, but could do with some making-of history and impact around the world |
[edit] Genres and gameplay
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
Adventure game |
Mid |
|
B |
Included in this table too for gameplay; references |
Beat 'em up |
Mid |
|
B |
|
City-building game |
Low |
|
B |
Could be treated together with Economic simulation game, of which this is a sub-genre |
Computer role-playing game |
Mid |
Desperately needs to be merged with Console RPG entry. Genres are not defined by platform in any other entry. There is a distinction between Computer and Console style RPGs, but there is also a great deal of cross pollination of ideas. |
B |
Long and listy. Needs refs if it's going to have a criticism section. |
Computer and video game genres |
Top |
|
B |
A discussion of genres might be required, but is also perhaps the most problematic topic since there is no real consensus on genres. Page reflect lack of consensus and references to existing research. Needs heavy rework, an extensive and objective discussion (rather than just a listing of a plentitude of genre-esque bullets) and references. |
Console role-playing game |
Mid |
|
B |
Economic simulation game |
Low |
|
Stub |
|
First-person shooter |
Mid |
|
B |
Lots of detail, but too much "game guide" stuff, and barely any refs. |
Government simulation game |
Low |
|
Stub |
A venerable part of gaming history, this article had to be stubified. Could use some good contributions. |
Massively multiplayer online game |
Mid |
|
Start |
|
Massively multiplayer online role-playing game |
Top |
|
A |
On our way to FA! |
Multiplayer game |
Mid |
|
B |
History? Multiplaying is not a genre, should be moved to another section. |
Racing game |
Mid |
|
Start |
Good for a "Short and listy" article. No history. |
Platform game |
Mid |
dominanted gaming in the 8 and 16 bit era more than any genre has before or since |
GA |
Current FA |
Real-time strategy |
Low |
Really higher importance than "low", but could be disussed under "strategy game" together with some other genres (turn-based strategy etc). |
B |
Really higher importance than "low", but could be disussed under "strategy game" together with some other genres (turn-based strategy etc).
Extensive history, exhaustive treatment. Lead and history should be included. History recently reworked, now clear, succing, without "listy" style, good treatment of history and classification problematics.
- (No refs; weasel words, for example, no discussion of WHY Warcraft and Warcraft 2 "arguably usherd in the era of contemporary RTS by its treatment of the burgeoning genre elements and grundbreaking popularity." -- Nifboy)
|
Real-time tactics |
Low |
|
B |
Recently restructured. Really higher importance than "low", but could be disussed under "strategy game" together with some other genres (turn-based strategy etc). |
Run and gun |
Low |
|
B |
New article that I (larsinio) wrote last week, although its pretty extensive as it is (well written, no refs, images need sources and FUR) |
Shoot 'em up |
Mid |
Its time's most characteristic genre. |
B |
Was re-written and organizaed as a part of a CGOTW, (well written, no refs, images need sources and FUR). |
Shooter game |
Mid |
|
B |
A decent disambig-style page. No history. |
Simulation game |
Mid |
|
Start |
Problematic entry; lack of focus and unclear definition ("simulation"/"simulator"). See article's talk page |
Sports game |
Mid |
|
Start |
"Types" section needs expansion, a history section is missing (Extreme Sports). |
Strategy game |
Mid |
|
Start |
Needs expansion. No history |
Strategy guide |
Low |
|
Start |
Needs expansion, sections... |
Third-person shooter |
Low |
|
Start |
Stublike. Not really necessary ("Shooter game" below will suffice) |
Turn-based strategy |
Low |
|
Start |
No history |
Turn-based tactics |
Low |
|
Start |
No history |
Versus fighting game |
Mid |
|
B |
|
[edit] Plot and characters
[edit] Industry and development
[edit] People
See also:
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
Tim Schafer |
Mid |
Creator of Grim Fandango, Psychonauts, etc. |
Start |
|
Ralph H. Baer |
High |
Creator of the first CVG console |
Start |
|
Seamus Blackley |
Low |
|
B |
|
Nolan Bushnell |
High |
Creator of PONG, kick-started the industry |
B |
|
John Carmack |
High |
Main programmer of Doom, Wolfenstein 3D and Quake |
B |
|
Richard Garriott |
High |
Creator of Ultima series; in many ways the father, or the evolver, of CRPGs. |
B |
|
Trip Hawkins |
Mid |
|
B |
|
Keiji Inafune |
Mid |
Creator of all the Mega Man and Onimusha series. Recently expanded, on par with Hideo Kojima |
B |
|
Shigesato Itoi |
Low |
Creator of the Mother games |
Start |
Needs expansion |
Frank Klepacki |
Low |
Composer of the original Command & Conquer series |
FA |
|
Hideo Kojima |
Mid |
Creator of the Metal Gear (series). |
B |
|
Ken Kutaragi |
High |
Father of the PlayStation |
B |
|
Jordan Mechner |
Mid |
Creator of Karateka, Prince of Persia, The Last Express, the first game designer to use rotoscoping (a predecessor to motion capture). |
Start |
No picture, birthdate, references. |
Sid Meier |
High |
Creator of Civilization (computer game) |
B |
|
Shinji Mikami |
Low |
Creator of the Resident Evil (series) (and other Capcom franchises). |
B |
|
Jeff Minter |
Low |
Creator of several updates of Tempest, as well as the Xbox 360's music visualiser. |
B |
|
Shigeru Miyamoto |
High |
Most widely-known and successful CVG developer, creator of Mario, Zelda, etc. |
B |
|
Peter Molyneux |
Low |
Creator of Populous, one of the first graphical 'god games'. |
Start |
|
Yuji Naka |
Low |
Creator of the Sonic the Hedgehog series. |
Start |
|
Yoshiki Okamoto |
Low |
Creator of the Street Fighter series, Founded Flagship. |
Start |
|
Alexey Pazhitnov |
Mid |
Creator of Tetris, arguably the most popular/recognized puzzle game, crucial to the success of Game Boy |
B |
|
Warren Robinett |
Low |
Game designer/programmer for various Atari 2600 games, including Adventure (Atari 2600) |
B |
|
John Romero |
Low |
Game designer for Doom, Wolfenstein 3D and Quake |
B |
|
Hironobu Sakaguchi |
Mid |
Creator of the Final Fantasy series. |
Start |
|
George Sanger |
Mid |
Video game musician: (The 7th Guest, Wing Commander, Maniac Mansion, others) |
Stub |
Too little information for having contributed to 200 games. No pic or refs. |
Yu Suzuki |
Low |
Creator of Out Run, Virtua Fighter, and Shenmue. |
B |
|
Satoshi Tajiri |
Low |
Creator of Pokémon. |
Start |
|
Takashi Tezuka |
Low |
Directed many Mario & Zelda games. |
Start |
|
Nobuo Uematsu |
Low |
Prolific video game music composer responsible for almost all the Final Fantasy soundtracks |
Start |
|
Roberta Williams |
Mid |
Creator of Mystery House (the first first-person game), King's Quest series, Phantasmagoria, all best-selling games. Did for adventure games what Meier and Wright did for strategy games, one of the most famous female video game designers. |
B |
Is about on par with the Sid Meier article. Needs more detail, refs. |
Will Wright |
High |
Creator of Sim City and The Sims |
B |
|
Hiroshi Yamauchi |
High |
President of Nintendo from 1949 until 2002. |
B |
|
Gunpei Yokoi |
Mid |
Creator of Game Boy, Game & Watch, and other systems |
B |
|
Bernie Stolar |
Low |
Had a demonstrable hand in Sega's later console troubles |
Start |
|
See also: Category:Defunct video game companies
[edit] Defunct companies
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
Atari |
High |
One of the oldest gaming companies; made one of the oldest game consoles (the 2600) |
B |
By far the best article of this bunch. Yellow article needs references badly, though. |
Brøderbund |
Low |
Prince of Persia, Carmen Sandiego, Myst |
Start |
|
Bullfrog Productions |
Mid |
Populous, Syndicate, Theme Park, Magic Carpet, Theme Hospital, Dungeon Keeper |
Stub |
Stublike. |
Enix |
Mid |
Dragon Quest, Star Ocean mostly. |
Stub |
might be worth merging to Square Enix. |
Epyx |
Low |
|
Start |
|
FASA |
Mid |
BattleTech, Star Trek (RPG), ShadowRun |
Start |
fine details; could benefit from graphics |
Epyx |
Low |
|
Start |
|
Looking Glass Studios |
Low |
Ultima Underworld, Ultima Underworld II: Labyrinth of Worlds, System Shock, Thief: The Dark Project |
Start |
|
MicroProse |
Mid |
Master of Orion, X-COM, founded by Sid Meier |
Start |
|
New World Computing |
Low |
Might and Magic, Heroes of Might and Magic (computer game), |
Start |
|
Origin Systems |
Mid |
Ultima, Wing Commander |
Start |
|
Sierra Entertainment |
Mid |
King's Quest, various published/developed games |
Start |
|
Square Co. |
High |
Final Fantasy and friends. |
Start |
|
The 3DO Company |
Low |
|
Start |
Not quite a stub, but close. |
Westwood Studios |
Mid |
Dune II, The Legend of Kyrandia, Lands of Lore, Command & Conquer |
Start |
|
See also: Category:Video game companies
[edit] Active companies
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
3D Realms |
Low |
Duke Nukem and nothing else. |
Start |
|
Activision |
High |
The first third-party developer; one of the biggest software publishers |
B |
|
Bethesda Softworks |
Low |
The Elder Scrolls series. |
Start |
Little more than a list of games. |
BioWare |
Low |
Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, various engines |
Start |
Nothing beyond the lists of games and engines. |
Blizzard Entertainment |
Mid |
Diablo, Warcraft, Starcraft. |
Start |
Too focused on Cease and Desists (POV). |
Capcom |
Mid |
Mega Man, Street Fighter, Resident Evil, and more. |
Start |
|
Cyan Worlds |
Mid |
Myst and sequels. |
Start |
Most of the article is a timeline. |
Eidos Interactive |
Low |
A relatively small publisher (Tomb Raider, Legacy of Kain) |
Start |
|
Electronic Arts |
High |
The biggest third party publisher. |
B |
Good info but tagged for cleanup. |
Epic Games |
Low |
Unreal Tournament, mostly. |
Start |
|
Id Software |
Mid |
Wolfenstein 3D, Doom, Quake |
B |
|
Konami |
Mid |
Castlevania, DDR, Metal Gear. |
B |
|
Lionhead Studios |
Low |
Black and White and Fable. |
Start |
|
LucasArts |
Low |
Monkey Island and many Star Wars games. |
Start |
|
Midway Games |
Mid |
Developer of Spy Hunter, Tron, Mortal Kombat, licensing & distribution of Pac-Man, Space Invaders... |
B |
|
Namco |
Mid |
Pac-Man, Soul Calibur, Tekken, Ridge Racer |
B |
|
Nintendo |
Top |
Major console and game maker for a long time |
B |
Removed from the GA. References might be cited in the article itself, unappropriate formatting. |
|
Rareware |
Mid |
Donkey Kong Country, GoldenEye 007, Banjo-Kazooie, and Perfect Dark |
B |
List needs to be put into a separate article |
Sega |
High |
Former major console maker |
B |
References. |
Sinclair Research |
Mid |
|
GA |
FAC page |
SNK Playmore |
Mid |
Neo-Geo, King of Fighters, Metal Slug, etc. |
B |
|
Sony Computer Entertainment |
Mid |
A subsidiary of Sony; creators of the Playstations |
B |
No history. |
Square Enix |
Mid |
Final Fantasy, Dragon Quest, Kingdom Hearts and others |
B |
|
Take-Two Interactive |
Low |
Owns Rockstar Games (GTA), others (2k Games, etc). |
Start |
A lead and a list of subsidiaries |
THQ |
Low |
Produces many different games. |
Start |
|
UbiSoft |
Mid |
Splinter Cell, Prince of Persia, Myst sequels, etc. |
Start |
Mostly a list of games. |
Williams (gaming company) |
Mid |
Basically the pinball company. |
B |
|
Valve |
Mid |
Developers of the Half-Life line and Counterstrike, amongst others |
Start |
Underdeveloped. |
[edit] Series
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
Carnivores games |
Low |
Probably the first hunting game series to break out of the traditional Deer Hunter mold |
Stub |
Recently extensively edited and expanded, may now be eligible for Start- or even B-Class status, still lacks lots of references |
Castlevania (series) |
Mid |
|
B |
|
Dance Dance Revolution (series) |
Mid |
|
B |
|
Dragon Quest (series) |
Mid |
|
B |
|
ESPN NFL 2K (series) |
Low |
|
Start |
Not much on what makes this series unique. |
Final Fantasy (series) |
Mid |
|
B |
No references, bullets could stand to be prose-ified. |
Fire Emblem (series) |
Mid |
|
B |
|
Grand Theft Auto (series) |
High |
Likely the most popular, stand-out franchise this past console generation. |
B |
No refs, long and listy. |
Gran Turismo (series) |
Mid |
|
Start |
King's Quest series |
Mid |
The first third-person adventure game, at its time one of the best-selling computer games of all time. |
Start |
Lacking in detail about games and history, no refs whatsoever and has a minor case of "list-syndrome". |
The Legend of Zelda series |
Mid |
|
GA |
Proper footnotes now. Still some work to be done. |
Madden NFL |
Mid |
|
B |
Madden Curse section should probably be split. Also, the only refs in the article refer to that and not the actual game series. |
Mega Man (series) |
Mid |
|
B |
Refs, long trivia section. |
Metal Gear (series) |
Mid |
|
B |
|
Metroid series |
Mid |
|
B |
Needs more sources (particularly when talking about reception), but otherwise fine. |
Monkey Island series |
Low |
|
B |
|
Pokémon ("franchise") |
Mid |
|
B |
Needs sources badly (esp. "controversy" section). Section on games could stand to be cleaned up. |
Resident Evil (series) |
Mid |
|
GA |
More expansion on impact/influence of series needed. |
SaGa |
Low |
Among Square games, SaGa is second to the Final Fantasy series in number of installments (it is also quite popular) |
Start |
Recently cleaned up, but still not quite B class |
Serious Sam |
Mid |
Brought a fresh, albeit simple, perspective into First Person Shooters which hadn't been seen since the days of Doom |
B |
Needs citations and more information, especially regarding reception and impact on the industry. Should probably be split up into several separate articles as well. |
Sonic the Hedgehog series |
Mid |
|
B |
Talks little about the later installments. Sources again. |
Street Fighter (series) |
Mid |
|
Start |
Lots of unsourced statements. Might have POV, technical concerns. |
Ultima (series) |
Mid |
|
B |
Critical entry, page links to games and is decent right now, but could use some expansion |
The Elder Scrolls (RPG series) |
Mid |
|
Start |
Mostly a list of the games of the series |
Dead or Alive (video game series) |
Low |
|
B |
Fixed. Greatly expanded, recently. Should be GA class. |
Spyro the Dragon (series) |
Low |
|
Start |
Quite goodly detailed... on the parts it has. Quite good but needs extending and updating. |
[edit] Computer games
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
3D Monster Maze |
High |
the 1st 3D game for a personal computer |
FA |
|
The 7th Guest |
Mid |
The very first computer game to only ship on CD-ROM (and two CD's at that). Mega hit when it first came out. |
Start |
Good gameplay and story section, but few references and a lot of needless lists. |
Age of Empires |
Mid |
|
B |
|
Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings |
Mid |
|
B |
|
Age of Empires III |
Mid |
|
GA |
|
BioForge |
Low |
Ahead of its time, somewhat overlooked, 1995 interactive movie game |
B |
Is well referenced, but failed a GA nom due to one missing reference and minor POV |
Civilization (computer game) |
High |
Megahit game (and one that changed the way we think about turn-based strategy) started a series that continues to this day. |
B |
No sources, but very applicable to the series as a whole (only played Civ4). |
Colossal Cave Adventure |
High |
The very first story-based adventure game. |
B |
|
Command & Conquer |
High |
Popularized RTS games |
Start |
Not enough info, to much on Music |
Command & Conquer: Red Alert |
High |
World record selling RTS game |
Start |
Not comprehensive, imbalanced, trivial, needs serious attention |
Counter-Strike |
High |
One of the most popular multiplayer online games ever |
B |
Detailed, but needs references and some rewriting |
Deus Ex |
Mid |
Recognized as an important evolution of the FPS/CRPG style of gameplay and winner of many awards |
B |
|
Diablo (computer game) |
Mid |
|
B |
Also: Diablo 2 |
Doom |
High |
A seminal title in the history of the first-person shooter genre and one of the most recognized gaming franchises |
FA |
|
Duke Nukem 3D |
Mid |
Well-known satirical FPS |
B |
Lacks refs, some sections need rewrite, excessive external links |
Duke Nukem Forever |
Low |
The most famous vaporware |
GA |
Not yet released |
Dune II |
High |
It's the precursor to the C&C franchise and established a few precedents for the RTS genre. |
B |
|
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion |
Mid |
One of the most well recieved games of 2006 and fastest selling XBox 360 game around console launch |
B |
Large and detailed but slightly negatively bias against it |
|
Everquest |
Mid |
|
B |
|
Fallout (computer game) |
Low |
|
Start |
|
Half-Life |
High |
Introduced interactive and scripted events into gameplay. Won over 50 game of the year awards. |
B |
What's up with FPSs and both really detailed plot and weapons sections? |
Half-Life 2 |
Mid |
|
FA |
|
Jet Set Willy |
Mid |
It was a significant developement in the platform game genre on the home micro. |
Start |
|
Klondike (solitaire) |
Mid |
Comes with Windows; most played game in the world |
Start |
|
KKnD |
Low |
|
Stub |
Needs expansion badly: one of Red Alert's main competitors at its time |
Lemmings (video game) |
Low |
Quite significant game in the 90s |
B |
Move to Amiga section if necessary |
Lineage II |
Low |
|
Start |
Lacks references. |
Minesweeper (computer game) |
Low |
comes with Windows |
Start |
|
Manic Miner |
Mid |
The game is notable for being among the most important pioneers in platform game genre. |
B |
|
Myst |
Mid |
The best-selling computer game of all time until it was unseated by The Sims. Has a devoted fan following. |
B |
|
Myth |
Mid |
Revolutionary combat engine and paved way for modern RTS and RTT. |
Start |
Way too much game guide material, too many lists, should be split up into seperate articles. |
NetHack |
Low |
|
B |
Refs, but seems lacking. Crufty? I don't know. |
The Oregon Trail (computer game) |
Mid |
|
B |
|
Prince of Persia |
Mid |
|
Start |
Disorganized, much info on other games in the series) |
Quake |
Mid |
Revolutionized FPS and deathmatch multiplayer gaming |
Start |
|
Serious Sam |
Mid |
Brought a fresh, albeit simple, perspective into First Person Shooters which hadn't been seen since the days of Doom |
B |
Needs citations and more information, especially regarding reception and impact on the industry. Should probably be split up into several separate articles as well. |
SimCity |
High |
Pioneered the city-building genre. The success of the game also paved the way for the development and release of other Sim games, including The Sims series. |
Start |
|
SimCity 2000 |
Low |
|
Start |
|
SimCity 3000 |
Low |
|
Start |
|
The Sims |
High |
The best selling computer game ever. |
B |
Needs to have a bit more depth to it |
The Sims 2 |
Low |
Sequal to the best selling computer game ever, cultural impact through music. Expanded to several platforms. |
B |
currently being rewritten with major clean-up. |
Snake (video game) |
Mid |
|
Start |
|
Spore (computer game) |
Low |
|
A |
Not-released yet but has already received several awards. |
StarCraft |
Mid |
First RTS with three totally different races; hugely popular and highly influential. |
FA |
|
Tomb Raider |
High |
|
Start |
|
Ultima Underworld |
Low |
|
Start |
|
Wolfenstein 3D |
High |
Hugely influential first-person shooter |
B |
|
World of Warcraft |
High |
|
B |
|
Zork |
High |
|
Start |
|
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
Castlevania |
Low |
|
B |
still needs some work (and refs) |
Dragon Quest (video game) |
Low |
Launched the most popular RPG series in Japan, set standards for console RPGs. |
Start |
|
Final Fantasy (video game) |
High |
Saved Squaresoft from ruin, launched a major RPG series. |
GA |
|
Mega Man |
Low |
|
B |
mostly lists, but OK |
Mega Man 2 |
Low |
|
Start |
Needs some expansion and a smaller Notes section |
Metroid |
Mid |
|
B |
Has Plenty of info. Not enough gameplay info though. |
The Legend of Zelda |
High |
Started the Zelda franchise, pioneer of the adventure genre. |
B |
pretty detailed |
Mike Tyson's Punch-Out!! |
Low |
|
Start |
Doesn't really cover the game's massive popularity in North America |
Rad Racer |
Low |
Not only was it the NES's premier racer, but it sold nearly 2 million copies. It was also one of the few games to feature those 3-D glasses |
B |
Needs to be expanded |
Super Mario Bros. |
Top |
Top selling video game series of all time, platforming standard. |
GA |
Besides a handful of small sections needing references, probably close to A-Class. |
Super Mario Bros. 3 |
High |
Highest selling stand-alone game, often cited as the best 2D platformer of all time. |
B |
Needs references. |
[edit] Sega Genesis/Mega Drive
[edit] Nintendo 64
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
Conker's Bad Fur Day |
Low |
|
B |
|
Goemon's Great Adventure |
Low |
Considered the highpoint of N64 sidescrollers |
A |
FA push once the plot is finalized |
GoldenEye 007 |
High |
Best-selling console FPS, introduced mission-based play |
B |
Needs refs, some sections need rewording |
The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask |
Low |
Virtually no impact compared to OoT. |
FA |
|
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time |
High |
Set the standard for 3D adventure games, often cited as the best CVG of all time, first perfect Famitsu score |
B |
Plot section is too big; Triforce section needs references. Confusing to non-specialists. Recently downgraded from GA status. |
Mario Kart 64 |
Low |
Same league as Perfect Dark, extremely popular but not revolutionary. Mario franchise. |
B |
Recently downgraded from GA status. |
Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon |
Low |
Considered first proto-RPG N64 title, a cross between Mario 64 and Zelda |
FA |
|
Perfect Dark |
Low |
Similar to GoldenEye 007, but neither more important nor more popular. |
FA |
Featured |
Star Fox 64 |
Mid |
First game to use Rumble Pak. |
GA |
|
Super Mario 64 |
High |
Pioneer in 3D platformers, drove N64 sales |
A |
Recently downgraded from FA; weasel/peacock words |
Super Smash Bros. |
Mid |
A popular, simple fighting game (traits that usually don't go together) |
B |
Lots and lots of lists. |
Paper Mario |
Mid |
New, innovative graphical style; sequel to Super Mario RPG |
B |
Some sections need expanding; Characters section needs cleanup |
Turok: Dinosaur Hunter |
Low |
Succesful third-party game. Three sequels, two in the N64 |
GA |
[edit] Nintendo DS
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
Animal Crossing: Wild World |
Mid |
Made the series one of the most successful series of all time in Japan; its success led to a highly popular motion picture, million seller |
B |
Could use a copyedit. Trivia section is huge. |
Brain Age |
High |
|
B |
Inspired a new demographic of gamers, one of the DS' most successful, spawned a new "genre" (Touch! Generations), million seller |
Kirby Canvas Curse |
Mid |
Considered the best Kirby game by many critics. |
B |
No references. needs more pictures. |
Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time |
Mid |
Million seller, decent critical response |
Start |
Not enough info on Gameplay. To much info on Plot. |
Mario Kart DS |
Mid |
Started Nintendo Wifi Connection, million seller, considered to be one of the best on DS (for instance, by Game Rankings) |
B |
|
Meteos |
Low |
Got a great deal of high ratings |
B |
|
Metroid Prime Hunters |
Mid |
Considered one of the best-looking DS games, with good reviews and sales exceeding 400,000 |
B |
Has Weasel Words |
New Super Mario Bros. |
Mid |
First Mario side-scroller in over 15 years, has done better than any Dragon Quest game in Japan, million seller, GotY in many places, one of the best-selling games on the DS in all regions |
B |
Plenty of info, not enough references. |
Nintendogs |
Mid |
Top-selling DS game, million seller, increased the % of female DS owners, considered to be the DS' first mega-hit |
B |
|
Pokémon Diamond and Pearl |
Mid |
Top-selling game in Japan, while unreleased outside. Sales exceeding 4.5 million, fastest-selling Pokémon title ever, first Pokémon to have online play |
GA |
|
Super Mario 64 DS |
Low |
The best-selling and highest-rated launch game in all regions, million seller, first Mario game for the DS |
B |
Needs more references. |
Tetris DS |
Low |
sales exceeding one million, first Tetris game developed by Nintendo since The New Tetris in 1999 |
B |
|
WarioWare: Touched! |
Mid |
million seller, best-selling WarioWare game |
Start |
|
Yoshi Touch & Go |
Low |
Decent sales and okay reviews |
B |
|
Kirby: Squeak Squad |
Mid |
million seller, and might manage to outsell all other Kirbies released in recent generations (has already beaten Amazing Mirror and Nightmare in Dream Land in Japan in two months) |
B |
|
Mario Hoops 3-on-3 |
Low |
sold exceptionally well in Japan and North America (reaching a figure of nearly 800,000), European release coming soon |
Start |
|
Pokémon Mystery Dungeon |
Mid |
million seller worldwide and in Europe for DS alone, nearly 800k in Japan, nearly 800k in NA |
Start |
|
Pokémon Ranger |
Mid |
million seller |
Start |
|
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney |
Low |
cult favorite, has sold well beyond Capcom's expectations and until recently, it had been selling out as fast as Capcom can put them on retail |
B |
|
Tamagotchi Connection: Corner Shop |
|
million seller, best-selling third party DS game (needs article!) |
|
[edit] Dreamcast
Article |
Need |
Rationale |
Quality |
Comments |
Jet Set Radio |
Mid |
Critically acclaimed, caused some controversy, pioneer in video game cel-shading style. |
Start |
Needs refs, expansion on gameplay. |
Shenmue |
Mid |
Huge franchise for Sega, although generally considered a failure. |
B |
|
Skies of Arcadia |
Mid |
Third highest selling Dreamcast game. Highest rated and highest selling Dreamcast RPG. |
Start |
|
Sonic Adventure |
High |
Top-selling Dreamcast game. Transition of a very famous franchise to true-3D. |
B |
Huge trivia section. List of characters should probably be split off. |
Soul Calibur |
Mid |
Killer app for the Dreamcast, arguably the most popular fighting game in recent times. |
Start |
Not much information on its popularity or importance in the life of the Dreamcast. |
Virtua Tennis |
Low |
Not a major title, compared to other Sega Sports games. |
Stub |
|
Need: A measure of a subject's importance, regardless of its quality
Top {{top-importance}} |
Subject is a must-have for a print encyclopedia. |
High {{high-importance}} |
Subject is exceptionally important. |
Mid {{mid-importance}} |
Subject contributes a depth of knowledge. |
Low {{low-importance}} |
Subject fills in important details. |
No {{no-importance}} |
Importance disputed; may be removed if inclusion is not justified. |
|
Video game
articles |
Importance |
Top |
High |
Mid |
Low |
None |
Total |
Quality |
FA |
2 |
10 |
19 |
11 |
|
42 |
A |
2 |
|
5 |
3 |
|
10 |
GA |
3 |
14 |
26 |
51 |
11 |
105 |
B |
30 |
96 |
220 |
325 |
391 |
1062 |
Start |
5 |
103 |
458 |
2205 |
3236 |
6007 |
Stub |
|
15 |
114 |
1965 |
7082 |
9176 |
Assessed |
42 |
238 |
842 |
4560 |
10720 |
16402 |
Unassessed |
0 |
0 |
0 |
1 |
159 |
160 |
Total |
42 |
238 |
842 |
4561 |
10879 |
16562 |
|
Article progress grading scheme [ v • d • e ]
Label |
Criteria |
Reader's experience |
Editor's experience |
Example |
FA
{{FA-Class}} |
Reserved exclusively for articles that have received "Featured article" status, and meet the current criteria for featured articles. |
Definitive. Outstanding, thorough article; a great source for encyclopedic information. |
No further editing is necessary unless new published information has come to light; but further improvements to the text are often possible. |
Supernova (as of February 2007) |
A
{{A-Class}} |
Provides a well-written, reasonably clear and complete description of the topic, as described in How to write a great article. It should be of a length suitable for the subject, with a well-written introduction and an appropriate series of headings to break up the content. It should have sufficient external literature references, preferably from "hard" (peer-reviewed where appropriate) literature rather than websites. Should be well illustrated, with no copyright problems. At the stage where it could at least be considered for featured article status, corresponds to the "Wikipedia 1.0" standard. |
Very useful to readers. A fairly complete treatment of the subject. A non-expert in the subject matter would typically find nothing wanting. May miss a few relevant points. |
Minor edits and adjustments would improve the article, particularly if brought to bear by a subject-matter expert. In particular, issues of breadth, completeness, and balance may need work. Peer-review would be helpful at this stage. |
Durian (as of March 2007) |
GA
{{GA-Class}} |
The article has passed through the Good article nomination process and been granted GA status, meeting the good article standards. This should be used for articles that still need some work to reach featured article standards, but that are otherwise good. Good articles that may succeed in FAC should be considered A-Class articles, but having completed the Good article designation process is not a requirement for A-Class. |
Useful to nearly all readers. A good treatment of the subject. No obvious problems, gaps, excessive information. Adequate for most purposes, but other encyclopedias could do a better job. |
Some editing will clearly be helpful, but not necessary for a good reader experience. If the article is not already fully wikified, now is the time. |
International Space Station (as of February 2007) |
B
{{B-Class}} |
Has several of the elements described in "start", usually a majority of the material needed for a completed article. Nonetheless, it has significant gaps or missing elements or references, needs substantial editing for English language usage and/or clarity, balance of content, or contains other policy problems such as copyright, Neutral Point Of View (NPOV) or No Original Research (NOR). With NPOV a well written B-class may correspond to the "Wikipedia 0.5" or "usable" standard. Articles that are close to GA status but don't meet the Good article criteria should be B- or Start-class articles. |
Useful to many, but not all, readers. A casual reader flipping through articles would feel that they generally understood the topic, but a serious student or researcher trying to use the material would have trouble doing so, or would risk error in derivative work. |
Considerable editing is still needed, including filling in some important gaps or correcting significant policy errors. Articles for which cleanup is needed will typically have this designation to start with. |
Munich air disaster (as of May 2006) has a lot of helpful material but contains too many lists, and needs more prose content & references. |
Start
{{Start-Class}} |
The article has a meaningful amount of good content, but it is still weak in many areas, and may lack a key element. For example an article on Africa might cover the geography well, but be weak on history and culture. Has at least one serious element of gathered materials, including any one of the following:
- a particularly useful picture or graphic
- multiple links that help explain or illustrate the topic
- a subheading that fully treats an element of the topic
- multiple subheadings that indicate material that could be added to complete the article
|
Useful to some, provides a moderate amount of information, but many readers will need to find additional sources of information. The article clearly needs to be expanded. |
Substantial/major editing is needed, most material for a complete article needs to be added. This article still needs to be completed, so an article cleanup tag is inappropriate at this stage. |
Real analysis (as of November 2006) |
Stub
{{Stub-Class}} |
The article is either a very short article or a rough collection of information that will need much work to bring it to A-Class level. It is usually very short, but can be of any length if the material is irrelevant or incomprehensible. |
Possibly useful to someone who has no idea what the term meant. May be useless to a reader only passingly familiar with the term. At best a brief, informed dictionary definition. |
Any editing or additional material can be helpful. |
Coffee table book (as of July 2005) |
|