Talk:23rd Street (Manhattan)
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
True or false: this article should be moved to West 23rd Street (New York) to clarify the city it is from in case there is another road with the same name in a different city in the United States. Because Wikipedia is not a local encyclopedia, there is no advantage of discriminating against regions of the United States other than New York City. 66.32.242.236 21:46, 2 Sep 2004 (UTC)
-
- If a street needs a signifier, it might be a sign that it's not an encyclopedia article. Fifth Avenue or Madison Avenue or Broadway, or Pall Mall, Ginza or Champs-Elysées etc don't need signifiers, and they are encyclopedia material. North Elm Street, Mytown isn't encyclopedic, but Elm Street might redirect to Nightmare on Elm Street. Think of getting useful information to a reader, and you'll rarely go wrong!. Wetman 21:55, 2 Sep 2004 (UTC)
