Talk:Audrey Santo
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This page claims a number of supernatural miracles to be facts. I am fairly confident that they have never been established as such.
[edit] Audrey Miracles
The bishop of Worcester has concluded that the events are supernatural, however further investigation is still ongoing.
- Riiiight! Because if the bishop of Worcester says so, then it must be true. 65.92.17.149 19:02, 30 November 2005 (UTC)
-
- That's not the issue. One can report what the Bishop has concluded without making it look like that means it's objectively true. --Bluejay Young 11:02, 10 January 2006 (UTC)
This wiki page is way too biased and quick to claim that this is miracle. First of all the oil supposededly oozing from the statues have been tested to be just vegatable oil and chicken fat, which is easily faked and manufactured, secondly never has the oil actually been observed to flow. Reports of "Stigmata" like wounds have mysteriously appeared on Audreys body, and she has been clamied to have been "mysteriously" moved. All this seems incredibly suspect. Especially when you consider that the Santos used to ship out cotton ball packets dipped in this oil to ask for donations. This whole thing seems to be a hoax, and an incredibly callous one aimed at the exploitation of a brain dead child. This wiki article neeeds to be edited to provide a more impartial view of what really could be going on by illuminating the arguments of the skeptics and the circumstances that surround the implications of a hoax.
- Well, this is wikipedia. All you have to do is fix it, which you (or someone) did. --Bluejay Young 01:31, 13 January 2006 (UTC)
[edit] audrey santo
hi there The article says that the miracles are "alleged" and does not claim them to be proven. To mention Audrey Santo in wikipedia without mentioning the miracle claims surrounding her would be false, as this is probably the reason audrey is mentioned in here in the first place. Check the website for the worcester diocese to get the facts about the investigation. NO, they are not an absolute authority, but they have conducted an official investigation and do not confirm or deny the miracles, hence the article uses the term "alleged".—The preceding unsigned comment was added by Priestessthesaurus (talk • contribs).
