Talk:Body mint
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
This article was nominated for deletion on 2006-12-16. The result of the discussion was Redirect to Chlorophyllin. |
[edit] Redirect to Chlorophyllin
I like the body mint article better than the cholorophyllin article. For example encouraging people to eat lettuce, cilantro, etc. for body mint effects. That is why I removed the redirect. Daniel.Cardenas 04:18, 13 December 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Non-noteable
Someone is claiming it is non-notable. According to Wikipedia:Notability the criteria for notable is that it has several independent articles on the subject. A google search shows up 30,000 hits. The cholorophyllin article is about cholorophyllin, while the body mint article is more about personal health and gives alternatives to odor control. I have removed the deletion tag for these reasons. Daniel.Cardenas 13:24, 16 December 2006 (UTC)
- That would be me, and please don't take it personally. (Unless you have some connection to the company making this product and are trying to advertise it, of course...) When I first saw this article, I took it for advertising - the only reason I didn't instantly slap it with a speedy-delete was that I thought the article was actually -better- than the one on chlorophyllin at the time. Not expecting any objection at all, I merged the non-brand-specific parts of this article into the one on chlorophyllin, and changed this page to a redirect. My proposed deletion was made in response to your restoring the article, hoping you would first see and then agree with my belief in its non-notability. But, as was your right, you removed the proposed-deletion notice and made it clear you disagree with me. :) However, I'm going to have to stand by my belief of the non-notability of this article, making it an WP:AFD proposal and bring the matter up for a formal discussion. - Pacula 19:56, 16 December 2006 (UTC)
