Talk:Idle RPG
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Contents |
[edit] Open Source ?
"Some code within this file was written by authors other than myself. As such, distributing this code or distributing modified versions of this code is strictly prohibited without written authorization from the authors." (from the header of the current version (3.1.2))
Doesn't really sound like OSS to me, sentence deleted.
—The preceding unsigned comment was added by 217.227.227.44 (talk • contribs) 12:09, March 24, 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Many versions
It'd seem that there's no single game that can claim to be the Idle RPG. While there's the original SlashNet version, which was the first version, other (more popular, even?) versions use the name Idle RPG as well. Therefore, I propose discussing all variants on Idle RPG, being an IRC RPG game where you idle, in this article.
--Kwi | Talk 19:52, 13 August 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Links section
Wikipedia is not an advertising service, and I guess most of the link section could be removed entirely, leaving only the notable IdleRPGs... I'm not going to decide which worthy of inclusion, however. So I've just reorganized the external links section, dividing into a section for actually notable versions, and the rest.
I've also removed weaselwords and most advertising language, sticking to mentioning their names and intended audience. (Also removed are the fact that all are modified in some way... we get it, already.)
And just to stay unbiased with regards to the order, I ran the "rest" section through sort.
--Kwi | Talk 19:52, 13 August 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Regarding external links
I see the external links section as a great opportunity for proponents and principals of Idle RPGs to use Wikipedia as advertisement, when in fact it should only be used for encyclopedic purposes--in this case, discussing the original and significant contributory versions of the game, the original on SlashNET and the GameSurge variant which was a significant reworking of the original. Therefore I think we should maintain an external links list that only consists of significant versions of the game, rather than any old version, since at this point there are tons. Bill Kramme 23:43, 15 December 2006 (UTC)
To go along with what Kwi has posted above, Wikipedia is not an advertising service and I'm getting a bit discouraged by the resilience of IRPG owners/players in adding a link to their own site after we've made it pretty clear we don't want just any site linked from here.
Unless your site is a significant change or derivative work on the concept of the Idle RPG (and you can support this without original research), it does not belong in the external links section. Please do not add any more links without justification for doing so. Bill Kramme 10:10, 3 January 2007 (UTC)
