Talk:Terry Brooks
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
This article is within the scope of WikiProject Biography. For more information, visit the project page. | ||
| ??? | This article has not yet received a rating on the Project's quality scale. Please rate the article and then leave a short summary here to explain the ratings and/or to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article. [FAQ] | ||
[edit] Tolkien
The concept of different races working together against a dark lord is not a new plot. Brooks has been considered to be a modern day Tolkien, because his writings are very similar, but hardly plagarism.
- "The concept of different races working together against a dark lord is not a new plot." -- I'd be interested in hearing of pre-Tolkien examples of this, from the original poster (page history says it's 12.41.204.3 ), or from anyone else. -- 01 November 2005
- Well if thats the case, hundreds of authors would be accused of plagarism. Perhaps George Lucas and his Star Wars movies is nothing but plagarism because his concept is of different races uniting against a dark force.--Jason Fox 14 December 2005
- The similarities run deeper than that. A quiet young man and his plucky companion set out on a quest to defeat a returning evil by use of an ancient talisman; in both books, the enemy has been powerful twice before, and his attempt to rise a third time is thwarted by the band of heroes. The plot is literally the same. A small party sets out from the quiet village Shady Vale/The Shire in search of the wizard Allanon/Gandalf (who started their quest in the beginning), stop in a medium-sized city (Leah/Bree - hmm, I never even noticed the rhyme) run into an ancient and inexplicable old man (The King of the Silver River/Old Tom Bombadil), then proceed on, slowed by spirits/Ringwraiths until they at last reach a haven of peace and power (Culhaven/Rivendell) where a team is assembled from different races, sets off on a mission, travels at length to the ancient Paranor/Moria, where the fellowship breaks and the two original characters set out on their own to defeat the Warlock Lord/Sauron while the others go help out in the wars the enemy is initiating all over. The main questers then defeat the Warlock Lord/Sauron with the help of the repulsive Orl Fane/Gollum who is really more interested in the Sword/the Ring than helping them out. I really don't understand what Terry Brooks was thinking. It's one thing to be mildly derivative, but it's quite another to borrow a book's plot and characters wholesale and then sprinkle in some minor changes. - Batkins 02:38, 12 January 2006 (UTC)
- Don't forget the part where the main character must battle a giant techno-spider/giant spider. And, his location is revealed whenever he uses the Elfstones/Ring of Power. There is a "difference", though. Shannara takes place on Earth, thousands of years in the future, whereas LoTR takes place on Earth, thousands of years in the past. I almost see the need for a comparisons article. --Philipacamaniac 08:56, 31 May 2006 (UTC)
- I think we should remove the paragraph about Sword's plot similarities to LOTR from this page for two reasons. First, it is discussed in detail in the Sword of Shannara page. Second, Brooks has written dozens of novels, and if this is an issue that needs to be in the opening paragraphs of his Wikipedia biography, then we need to cite legitimate references that show that this was a major and important controversy for its time. I don't deny that there are many, many similarities, but again, is this opening paragraph information? If so, cite the sources. I would like delete it soon unless there are major objections. --sraan 2 July 2006
