Talk:Upgrade U
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Upgrade U was released as a single in 2006 as a 12" single and the video took until 2007 to premire so stop saying it's not a single because it is.
It was release on promotional 12" singles - Noboyo
Contents |
[edit] Hold Up!
wasnt upgrade u releade on the 12" thing before listen? doesnt that mean it goes before it on the timeline? 24.218.70.219 21:44, 5 March 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Song or Single infobox
As I see it, the song has a video and has been serviced to radio and DJs as a 12" single and is available commerically as a digital download and has seen chart action, so it should have a single infobox, not a song infobox. Can we have a real discussion here instead of editing back & forth, please? - eo 15:02, 8 March 2007 (UTC)
You have to make a difference between "promotional release only" and "real singles". "Upgrade U" has NOT been released as an official single yet, but received airplay and download success some time ago - that's why it charted on the Billboard Hot 100. It's just an album cut. - Noboyo
- Even if it's a "promotional release", it should still be using {{Infobox Single}}. {{Song infobox}} is meant for well-known songs like "867-5309/Jenny" that were never released as singles, promotional or otherwise. That's why there's no field for the release format (the "Released" field is supposed to be a date). ShadowHalo 07:38, 24 March 2007 (UTC)
- A single infobox should be used for singles - not for charted album cuts. - Noboyo
- A promotional single is still a type of single though. That's why the song infobox doesn't have a field for the release format. ShadowHalo 00:37, 1 April 2007 (UTC)
- A single infobox should be used for singles - not for charted album cuts. - Noboyo
[edit] Why Not?
If LeToya Lucketts Single chronology can include two promotional singles ("You Got What I Need" & "All Eyes on Me (LeToya song)") then why cant this promotional single be added?
[edit] Why Not?
If LeToya Lucketts Single chronology can include two promotional singles ("You Got What I Need" & "All Eyes on Me (LeToya song)") then why cant this promotional single be added?
