Category talk:Logicians
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] Hegel a logician?
I oppose Hegel's inclusion in this category.
True: Hegel called parts of his philosophy "logic".
True: There are no completely precise and universally accepted criteria as to what is and what isn't logic.
But: The parts of Hegel's philosophical output which he called "logic" are so dramatically different from what anybody else in the category produced, and from the methodological standards anybody else in the category upheld, that Hegel shouldn't be in here. Calling something "logic" does not make it logic.
--Skon 16:38, 28 February 2007 (UTC)
