User:Naconkantari/cleanup/poll

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This poll is scheduled to be "closed" on 30 March at 23:59 UTC, however you may still continue voting/discussion after the deadline. Please note that this vote is not for the approval or disapproval of the proposal, i.e. if the consensus was to support the proposal, it would still have to have a final approval by the community. This vote is primarily to modify the proposal into something that the community would support. With all that being said, please take the time to review the proposal and vote accordingly. Thanks, Naconkantari 05:44, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

Contents 1 main 1.1 General consensus 1.1.1 I support this proposal as written 1.1.2 I would support this proposal if certain aspects were modified 1.1.3 I do not support this proposal in any form 2 logistics 2.1 Restricted editing 2.1.1 Approve as is (Disable editing for non-autoconfirmed accounts) 2.1.2 Modify to disable editing for non-logged in users only (allow non-autoconfirmed) 2.1.3 Modify to other setting (please provide details) 2.2 Restricted page creation 2.2.1 Approve as is (Disable new page creation for non-administrators) 2.2.2 Modify to enable page creation for all autoconfirmed editors (no change from current policy) 2.3 Restricted account creation 2.3.1 Approve as is (Disable new account creation) 2.3.2 Remove this restriction 2.4 Anonymous input 2.4.1 Approve mailing list creation 2.4.2 Approve meta page creation (Create a page on meta where restricted editors can suggest changes) 2.4.3 Approve both 2.4.4 Approve neither 2.4.5 Other (please provide details) 2.5 Deletion process (Non-speedy) 2.5.1 Approve as is (Suspend XFD and DRV, protect with cascading protection, one-day extension) 2.5.2 Modify to suspend and protect XFD and DRV with no extension (Administrators can close XFDs and DRVs as scheduled) 2.5.3 Modify to not suspend or protect XFD and DRV 2.5.4 Other (please provide details) 2.6 Deletion process (speedy) 2.6.1 Approve as is (Speedy deletions on articles will be done as necessary and may be contested at DRV when the cleanup period ends) 2.6.2 Modify to approve as is with the exception that SD candidates classified as "A7" or "G11" be allowed to stay if contested 2.6.3 Modify to approve as is with the exception that any SD candidates be allowed to stay if contested 2.6.4 Modify to approve as is with the exception that "A7" or "G11" candidates may be deleted but may be automatically restored if requested on DRV the next day (Similar to prod) 2.6.5 Other (please provide details) 2.7 Deletion process (prod) 2.7.1 Approve as is (Prods will not be suspended or extended) 2.7.2 Modify to extend prods expiring within the cleanup period by one day 2.7.3 Modify to extend all prods affected by one day 2.7.4 Other (please provide details) 2.8 RFA process 2.8.1 Approve as is (Suspend creation of RFAs, extend RFAs closing withing the cleanup period by one day) 2.8.2 Approve as is but suspend entire RFA process by means of cascading protection 2.8.3 Modify to not suspend RFA (Note that if Restricted page creation is approved, an administrator will be required to create the nomination page) 2.8.4 Other (please provide details) 2.9 Arbitration process 2.9.1 Approve as is (Delay by one day if an active participant is not an autoconfirmed editor, otherwise no change) 2.9.2 Modify to suspend Arbitration (with the exception of Arbitrators) for the cleanup period by means of cascading protection 2.9.3 Modify to not suspend Arbitration 2.9.4 Other (please provide details) 3 Interface Modifications 3.1 Site Notice (before cleanup period) 3.1.1 Option 1 3.1.2 Option 2 3.1.3 No sitenotice 3.2 Site Notice (during cleanup period) 3.2.1 Option 1 3.2.2 Option 2 3.2.3 No sitenotice 3.3 Account creation page 3.3.1 Option 1 3.3.2 Option 2 3.3.3 No account creation page notice 4 Time and Date 4.1 Time 4.1.1 0:00 UTC to 23:59 UTC 4.1.2 Other (please provide details) 4.2 Date 5 Other 5.1 Question 1 5.1.1 Yes 5.1.2 No

[edit] main

[edit] General consensus

[edit] I support this proposal as written

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] I would support this proposal if certain aspects were modified

1. -Amarkov moo! 00:13, 24 March 2007 (UTC)
2. MER-C 05:26, 24 March 2007 (UTC)
3. DGG 06:06, 24 March 2007 (UTC)
4. Jaranda ^{wat's sup} 17:34, 24 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] I do not support this proposal in any form

Captain panda In vino veritas 00:12, 24 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] logistics

[edit] Restricted editing

[edit] Approve as is (Disable editing for non-autoconfirmed accounts)

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)
• DGG 06:07, 24 March 2007 (UTC)
• MER-C 12:49, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Modify to disable editing for non-logged in users only (allow non-autoconfirmed)

[edit] Modify to other setting (please provide details)

[edit] Restricted page creation

[edit] Approve as is (Disable new page creation for non-administrators)

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)
• It's better having deletionists getting rid of crappy "articles" that already exist, rather than being distracted by new page patrol. MER-C 12:44, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Modify to enable page creation for all autoconfirmed editors (no change from current policy)

• DGG 06:07, 24 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Restricted account creation

[edit] Approve as is (Disable new account creation)

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Remove this restriction

• Captain panda In vino veritas 00:15, 24 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Anonymous input

[edit] Approve mailing list creation

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Approve meta page creation (Create a page on meta where restricted editors can suggest changes)

[edit] Approve both

[edit] Approve neither

• Captain panda In vino veritas 00:16, 24 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Other (please provide details)

[edit] Deletion process (Non-speedy)

[edit] Approve as is (Suspend XFD and DRV, protect with cascading protection, one-day extension)

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Modify to suspend and protect XFD and DRV with no extension (Administrators can close XFDs and DRVs as scheduled)

• Better. MER-C 12:32, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Modify to not suspend or protect XFD and DRV

[edit] Other (please provide details)

[edit] Deletion process (speedy)

[edit] Approve as is (Speedy deletions on articles will be done as necessary and may be contested at DRV when the cleanup period ends)

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Modify to approve as is with the exception that SD candidates classified as "A7" or "G11" be allowed to stay if contested

[edit] Modify to approve as is with the exception that any SD candidates be allowed to stay if contested

[edit] Modify to approve as is with the exception that "A7" or "G11" candidates may be deleted but may be automatically restored if requested on DRV the next day (Similar to prod)

[edit] Other (please provide details)

[edit] Deletion process (prod)

[edit] Approve as is (Prods will not be suspended or extended)

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Modify to extend prods expiring within the cleanup period by one day

[edit] Modify to extend all prods affected by one day

[edit] Other (please provide details)

[edit] RFA process

[edit] Approve as is (Suspend creation of RFAs, extend RFAs closing withing the cleanup period by one day)

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Approve as is but suspend entire RFA process by means of cascading protection

[edit] Modify to not suspend RFA (Note that if Restricted page creation is approved, an administrator will be required to create the nomination page)

[edit] Other (please provide details)

[edit] Arbitration process

[edit] Approve as is (Delay by one day if an active participant is not an autoconfirmed editor, otherwise no change)

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Modify to suspend Arbitration (with the exception of Arbitrators) for the cleanup period by means of cascading protection

[edit] Modify to not suspend Arbitration

[edit] Other (please provide details)

[edit] Interface Modifications

Please feel free to add your own options to any of the sections. Also, feel free to propose a change to other MediaWiki elements by creating a new section.

[edit] Site Notice (before cleanup period)

[edit] Option 1

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Option 2

[edit] No sitenotice

[edit] Site Notice (during cleanup period)

[edit] Option 1

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Option 2

[edit] No sitenotice

[edit] Account creation page

[edit] Option 1

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Option 2

[edit] No account creation page notice

[edit] Time and Date

[edit] Time

[edit] 0:00 UTC to 23:59 UTC

• Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Other (please provide details)

[edit] Date

There would be too many sections for a specific date, please propose dates and discuss the benefits/concerns of each

• I feel that the date should either be Tuesday, April 15 or Saturday, April 20 as this would allow enough time for ample advance notice to be given. *Naconkantari 05:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Other

[edit] Question 1

[edit] Yes

[edit] No