Talk:Vestal Review
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This article presents an odd series of associative lists. Starting with a list of contributors, which is generally acceptable, it goes on to list other places where these contributors have appeared, which has nothing to do with the magazine, then goes even further to list publishers that have published novels by contributors, which has even less to do with the magazine, limited as it is to Flash Fiction.
Is the purpose of this to show how important and hip the magazine is, by discovering new talents? Wouldn't it be better to tell us more about the magazine itself, rather than try to defend its inclusion in wikipedia by piling on vaguely relevant links? For now this article seems to be strictly promotional. AshcroftIleum 22:29, 8 January 2007 (UTC)
