Talk:Jamaat-e-Islami Bangladesh
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
Jamaat-e-Islami Bangladesh is part of WikiProject Bangladesh, which aims to improve Wikipedia's coverage of Bangladesh and Bangladesh-related topics. If you would like to participate, visit the project page. Please do not subsitute this template.
|
| Start | This article has been rated as Start-Class on the quality scale. |
| Mid | This article has been rated as Mid-importance on the importance scale. |
I shifted the page here from Bangladesh Islamic Assembly, since the English form of the name is never used. English language media in Bangladesh and abroad refer to the party as "Jamaat". The history of the article can be found here. --Soman 23:22, 21 Dec 2004 (UTC)
Contents |
[edit] Jamaat's Role in the Liberation War
As far as I'm concerned Rajakar was formed by the Pakistani Army. Would the author look into this please?
[edit] Edit by wisesabre
I have removed link Gun culture in Pakistan. this link had nothing to do with the article.
and also removed 'is alleged to be a part of the Al-Qaeda network.' because there is no proof of it.You should provide any reasonable proof about this statement.الثاقب (WiseSabre| talk) 15:59, 3 September 2005 (UTC)
[edit] No Politics here please
Do not play the game of politics here, please. Only include what you know for sure. Specially linking Jamaat with bombings and then AL with attacking their own office, well, that is just trying to play down each other. Conspiracy theories should go under the 'conspiracy theory' section, not under normal headings.
[edit] Sources?
There's a lot of assertion in the article, and a distinct lack of sources. Could someone provide these, before this turns into a full-on POV dispute? Alai 17:54, 11 September 2005 (UTC)
[edit] This is a partisan/partial entry
Having seen the evolution of this page, starting off as an Awami League rant, I doubt the authenticity of this page. No sources, libelous assertions, and basically a charge sheet of the Jamaat. Note this page and the Awami League page
[edit] Restoring NPOV
This article is full of shit. I have removed all false allegations against Jamaat to restore NPOV.
"non-Islamic political process such as democracy"
Democracy is not a non-islamic process.
"government which establishes and condones non-Islamic law"
Subjective statement. Non-Islamic laws are not established or condoned here in Bangladesh.
"non-Islamic nationalist and socialist political outfits such as the BNP and the Jatiya Party"
False statements. Who says they are non-Islamic?
"Jamaat ... overtly nationalistic party, whose views and expressions parallel that of Pakistani socialism"
False statements. Period.
"uses the name of Islam as a political facade"
Subjective statement. According to the party manifesto, it wants to ESTABLISH Islam, not to use it. It is clear that "establishing Islam itself in the society" and "using Islam to gain power" are quiet different things.
"however have been ignored by the current government"
Confusing statement. The current government is no authority to deny such allegations.
"Jamaat's political branch in Pakistan"
JI Bangladesh and JI Pakistan are independent organisations. They are not branches as there is no instrumental link. Both however, are subscriber of same ideology.
" Rajakar also raped women aged upto 60. At least 10,000 women were raped by them. Children born by this were taken taken to Mother Teresa's Missionaries of Charity at calcutta or adopted by Canada-US-Europe families."
Such historical claims require citation of historic documents and references.
"... victims were young ..."
And old, too.
several Jamaat leaders fled to West Pakistan. Golam Azam fled on 3rd December
False statement. No Jamaat leader fled to EP. Golam Azam came to Dhaka from London. But he was not allowed an entry here. Then he flew to Pakistan as he only had a Pakistani passport to claim his citizenship.
"introduced multiparty democracy in order to use Islamic sentiment to country"
LOL! How come democracy can be introduces to "use" Islamic sentiment?
"... still has strong ties with Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan ... mastermind behind a series of deadly terrorist attacks ... against ... foregners and minorities ..."
False statements. These are not qualified even as allegations!
[edit] Lets keep Bangladeshi Wiki pages free from the country's usual, debilitating partisan politics
Once again this page has been vandalised by partisan Awami Leaguers. All the sources cited here are from pro-Awami League sources. This is not neutral and defies Wikis definition of neutrality. Check pervious versions. If it was neutral, it would give Jamaat's side of the story.
[edit] To user: Rising India
You can’t revert other people’s edits without reasons. I will be happy to talk to you about my edit, please tell me where you disagree. One of the reasons why Jamaat-e-Islami is gaining popularity, which is a fact, is because they are seen as the least corrupt party by most Bangladeshis. This is one of fact that many Western journalists and anti-Islamic-fundamentalist mentions. This is an encyclopedia, therefore this has to be mentioned as one of the reasoning why Jamaat-e-Islami is gaining popularity.
You may think I am being bias toward Jamaat-e-Islami but look at my entire edits. I deleted many things that favor Jamaat-e-Islami because it creates NPOV and this is an encyclopedia, those individual stories don't belong here. I deleted
"After the Four-Party Alliance handed over power to the caretaker government, on the 28th of October, 4 Jaamat workers were mercilessly killed by Awami League workers in front of the media. The whole world bore witness to the merciless killings. The daily star also printed a picture showing a Jaamat worker with a gun, but it was later revealed that the image was taken on the 22nd of April, not on the 28th of October, proving the partiality of the media."
I deleted this sentece which also favors Jamaat-e-Islami, The Mukti Bahini was responsible for the killing of many people, including Jaamat members and Biharis.
I deleted because it is not accurate because Mukti Bahini in general didn't target Jaamat members, they targeted traitors which may happens to be Jaamat members. Tarikur 18:06, 31 January 2007 (UTC)
