Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive contents

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This report has been generated because of a request at Wikipedia talk:Notability (web). It covers the archives that match Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive <#>, Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive <#>
Report generated at 03:23, 7 April 2007 (UTC) by ^HBCAI

---

Discussion Topic	Replies (estimated)	Archive Link
"Alexa rankings over 10,000 may not be accurate," etc.	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
"Websites of similar reliability to published works"	12	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
"Wikipedia may contain content that some readers consider objectionable or offensive."	18	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
10%?	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
10%?	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
5000?	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
5000 members = 16500 posts?	7	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
A modest webcomic proposal	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
A modest webcomic proposal	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
A question on subculture notability	15	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
A random observation	8	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Additional Criteria	13	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Additional Criteria	16	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Advertising/Web directory	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Alexa	6	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Alexa	6	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Alexa	43	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Alexa rankings	18	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Alexa rankings	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Alexa revisited	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Alexa revisited	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Alternative blanket proposal	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Alternative blanket proposal	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Alternative ways of qualifying are needed	10	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Amazon ranking guideline is so extremely easy to pass that it's meaningless	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
An excellent start	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
An interesting AfD	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Any article should say something worth saying	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Any article should say something worth saying	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Archives	Unknown	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 06
AtomFilms	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Audience size	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Award examples	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Blogging	14	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Blogs	21	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Bold replacement of old guideline proposals	6	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Bold replacement of old guideline proposals	6	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Bringing this in line with larger consensus	16	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Can we please now stop with the hyperbole about "purges" thank you?	12	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Centrality of WT:N	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Change Notability Requirements for Wiki/MediaWiki Projects	19	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Change template	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Clarify application to USENET newsgroups	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Comixpedia/Websnark as a reliable source?	30	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Companies	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Company sites	8	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Company sites	8	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Comparisons section relevant and necessary?	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Conflicts of interest	26	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Conflicts of interest	26	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Confusing Criteria	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Consensus for Speedy Deletables	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Consensus for Speedy Deletables	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Content distribution	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Copied from Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Webcomics/Notability and inclusion guidelines	6	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Copied from Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Webcomics/Notability and inclusion guidelines	6	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Criteria - reference	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Criteria	17	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Criteria	17	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Criteria for non-Website internet material	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Databases	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Disambiguation standards	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Disambiguation standards	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Disputed	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Disputed tag?	16	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Disputed tag	9	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Disputed tag	21	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Distribution means what	14	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Does this meet the criteria?	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Does WIKIPEDIA conform with its own criteria?	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Draft for an improved Alexa proposal	28	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Draft for an improved Alexa proposal	28	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Educational sites	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Expand The Criteria!!	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Failings on Bloggers	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Failings on Early Web History	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Formerly with a publisher	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Forum Requirements	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Forums	15	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Forums	15	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Forums	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Forums in the Notability Guidelines...	14	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 06
Game box review quotes	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Games distributed exclusively on the Internet	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
General notability guideline template	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Good Faith	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Google/Alexa	10	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Google/Alexa	10	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Google	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Guideline for internet memes	22	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Historical value	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Historical value	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Hmmm... webcomic Alexa 100,000	10	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
How "Well Known" is "Well Known"?	19	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Hundreds of articles about blogs	8	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
I'm sorry	Unknown	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Inclusion	14	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Inclusion	14	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Internet Portal	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Is this a guideline?	11	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Keenspot	42	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Keenspot	28	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Keenspot	28	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Killing points	15	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Killing points	15	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
lets make some things clear	6	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 06
Looking at Comixpedia "magazine articles"	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Looking for a third path	68	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Main page	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Main page revolving door	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Major Edit (again)	17	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Match WP:V?	36	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Mechinima	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Meme AfDs	8	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Merge	21	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Merge of "meme" guideline	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Merge Request	22	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 06
Misuse of WP:WEB to steamroll Vfd	14	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Move this sideways and onwards	26	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
My opinion (inc a few tips)	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
My opinion (inc a few tips)	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Need Opinions	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
New idea	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
New idea	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
New multi-criterion proposal	92	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
New multi-criterion proposal	92	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
New Revision	12	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Non-notable, non-professional syndicates	13	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Non-notable, non-professional syndicates	13	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Not policy	15	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Notability based on something other than popularity or longevity?	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Notability based on something other than popularity or longevity?	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Notability inquiry	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Notability is the wild west of Wikipedia	17	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Notability of nexi of points of view	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
notability template	8	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
notability template	8	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Notability vs. Uniqueness	15	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Notable syndicates	24	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Notable syndicates	24	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Note creep?	9	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Old Alexa	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Onus on the deleter	11	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
PageRank	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
PageRank and back-links	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
PageRank and back-links	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Podcasts (again)	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Podcasts	6	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Podcasts	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Policy	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Problems with Alexa rankings	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Proof of notability	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Proposed non-notability template	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Proposed non-notability template	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Published in a paper magazine	8	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Question regarding online groups	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Question Regarding Sites as Links	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Question Regarding Sites as Links	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Ranking	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Ranking	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Relevance outside the subject matter	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Relevance outside the subject matter	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Reliable Sources?	19	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Reliable Sources for a game? Or advertisement catalogue instead of encyclopedia	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Remaining Objections	7	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Remaining Objections	7	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Removal of paragraphs about awards and distribution	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Removed a link	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Requested move	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Requested move	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Revert, discuss changes	10	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Small edits/major edits	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
So I'm "wildly out of touch"?	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Sources	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Sources	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Sources	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Speedy?	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 06
Speedy deletion and web notability criteria	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
State of play	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
StrategyWiki	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Stupid	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Suggested tweak:	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Suggestion	21	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Suggestion Requested	24	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Suggestion that Wikipedia:Notability be merged into Bad Jokes and Other Deleted Nonsense	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 06
Suggestion that WP:MEMES be merged into WP:WEB	20	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 06
Summary of old webcomic discussions	21	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Tentative rule for notability	12	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 06
Text removal from "Other" section	11	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
The persistent controversy shows that the notability criteria violate common sense	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
These guidelines are primarily designed...	17	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
this guideline isn't really a guideline	18	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 06
Thoughts on Inclusion Criteria	16	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Thoughts on Inclusion Criteria	16	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Time-based criteria	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Traffic ranking	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Updated guidelines	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Web Cartoonist's Choice award	6	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Web content vs. webspecific content.	2	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Webby Awards	4	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Webcomics	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Webcomics again	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Webcomics again	7	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Webcomics Artist Collectives and Co-ops	22	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
Websites	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Websites	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
Websites	42	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Where have we "failed"	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Where is the link with verifiability?	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 05
Why revert minor change?	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
Wikipedia:Notability (web): multiple or two or more	26	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)
Wikipedia is not a web directory?	3	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 03
Wikiproject: Webcomics	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
Wikiproject: Webcomics	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
WP:COMIC	16	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
WP:COMIC	16	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02
WP:CON vs WP:BOLD	33	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 04
WP:WEB and content distribution	1	Wikipedia talk:Notability (web)/Archive 07
WP:WEB and forking	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 01
WP:WEB and forking	5	Wikipedia talk:Notability (websites)/Archive 02