Talk:Savoy opera

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

	This article is part of WikiProject Gilbert and Sullivan, an attempt to complete and improve the Gilbert and Sullivan related articles on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, you can edit the article attached to this page, or visit the project page, where you can join the project and see a list of open tasks.
B	This article has been rated as B-Class on the quality scale.
Top	This article has been rated as Top-importance on the importance scale for the G&S Project.
Article Grading: The article has been rated for quality and/or importance but has no comments yet. If appropriate, please review the article and then leave comments here to explain the ratings and/or to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article.

Contents 1 Original comment 2 Revised definition 3 Duplicated list 4 Operetta

[edit] Original comment

Patience opened at the Opera Comique, but it was transferred to the just-opened Savoy Theatre partway through its run; hence its being the first of the "real" Savoy Operas. Psmith 19:13, 12 Oct 2003 (UTC)

Okay. In that case the definition should read "written for first performance at the Savoy Theatre" or "intended for first performance at the Savoy Theatre" rather than "performed at the Savoy Theatre", since all the shows were performed at the Savoy eventually. I had interpreted "performed at the Savoy Theatre" to mean "first performed at the Savoy Theatre" -- hence starting with Iolanthe -- but if you think that a different definition is more in line with common usage in order to make Patience first, then let's put that definition into the article. -- Derek Ross

It's certainly standard usage in my experience for Patience to be considered a

Savoy Opera even in the strictest sense; I've changed the definition to one that : reflects this more clearly. Psmith 20:05, 12 Oct 2003 (UTC)

[edit] Revised definition

The prior edit defined "Savoy Opera" as:

The Savoy Operas are a series of comic operas or operettas written by Gilbert and Sullivan. Strictly speaking, the term refers only to those whose first run or part thereof occurred at the Savoy Theatre in London (those from Patience onwards); in practice, the term is used more generally to refer to all the operas written by librettist W. S. Gilbert and composer Arthur Sullivan, and produced by Richard D'Oyly Carte.

I don't think there's any historical basis for the rather pedantic idea that, "strictly speaking," Savoy Opera includes only those operas whose first run was entirely, or in part, at the Savoy. Moreover, at the time they were being written, "Savoy Opera" referred to a style, of which G&S were the pre-eminent, but not exclusive, practitioners. The contemporary press, of course, could not have guessed that all of those other works would pass into near-oblivion, leaving the G&S pieces to stand alone for a genre that originally included far more.

The revised definition, I hope, captures the idea more accurately. Marc Shepherd 16:27, 12 June 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Duplicated list

I don't like the fact that the list of G&S Savoy operas is in the introduction and then repeated (and expanded) in the table lower down. Any objections to removing it? --Jmptdc 15:23, 25 July 2006 (UTC)

You're right. However, if you look at the G&S Project page, I think we say something about a plan to move it to a "see also" list. I think this article should have the FULL list of operas played at the Savoy (including curtain raisers), but that we should note that the term Savoy Opera is usually used as a synonym for just the 14 G&S operas. May I suggest that you wait until Marc Shepherd returns before dealing with this redundancy? Best regards, --Ssilvers 20:21, 25 July 2006 (UTC)

The problem is that the term "Savoy Opera" has meant different things at different times. In modern parlance, "Savoy Opera" is practically synonymous with the thirteen operas G&S wrote for Richard D'Oyly Carte. Indeed, before I joined Wikipedia, the leading sentence of the present article said, "The Savoy Operas are a series of comedy operas or operettas written by Gilbert and Sullivan," and the article did not mention the existence of any others.

Originally, of course, Richard D'Oyly Carte employed other composers and librettists, and "Savoy Opera" meant anything written for that theatre. Those other works didn't achieve a foothold in the standard repertory, leaving the G&S works as an apparently isolated phenomenon.

As this is an Encyclopedia for the general reader, I think it's appropriate to call out — right up front — the thirteen works that most people would expect to see. The article then goes on to explain the history in more detail, and provides the longer list, which includes a large number of works that are seldom or never revived.

The two lists, of course, are not strictly duplicates; they provide different information. Marc Shepherd 01:16, 27 July 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Operetta

Carte intended his 'English' operas to banish French operetta from the London stage. In any case, there is no reason to remark on operetta here. It is true that the Savoy Operas influenced modern musicals, and we should not try to compare them to operettas in this article. This article has other issues to deal with. -- Ssilvers 05:48, 27 March 2007 (UTC)