User talk:MrASingh
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Contents |
[edit] So far no criticism - yey!
[edit] (Ill-founded, simple-minded and illogical, AND simplistically stated*) Criticism
Sorry to have to be the first. Your recent edits to Race and crime are unacceptable. Adding over 80 banners to any article is not an appropriate way approach a content dispute; it is vandalism. I have removed most of the banners and have left 6 of the most appropriate and helpful banners at the top. Please see Talk:Race and crime for more information. Thank you. Joie de Vivre 00:53, 18 March 2007 (UTC)
- If I have the ability to back-up each and everyone of those banners (which, BTW, I DO - though, perhaps, I don't have the time necessary) then I believe that EACH and EVERY one of those banners is well-justified by the most lofty moral standards of wikipedia.
- Now, I'll try to address each of your points in a reasonable way :
1) Your recent edits to Race and crime are unacceptable.
> Hopefully I can argue against this.
2) Adding over 80 banners to any article is not an appropriate way approach a content dispute;
> This is dependent upon the length of the article in general. Though you might argue that several of those 80 banners were unnecessary (for example, repeating banners at the section level when the criticism they entail is just a repetition of an article wide banner), the number of banners used to raise *issues* does seem to be quite a trifling concern my good fellow.
3) it is vandalism.
> Those are harsh words. I will have to refer to Wikipedia:Vandalism. I do not believe that I have *deliberately* attempted to compromise the integrity of Wikipedia. In fact, it has been my attempt to do the opposite that you are criticising as vandalism (even if I have conceded that some of the banner additions may have been unnecessary). I will assume that you have alluded to the possible interpretation of my acts as conceivably being 'over-the-top'. 'Vandalism' should be replaced by 'zealousness'. [User:MrASingh|MrASingh]] 15:56, 19 March 2007 (UTC)
- Response at bottom of the page. Joie de Vivre 20:31, 19 March 2007 (UTC)
- - Not all simple-minded criticism is simplistically stated. Like a salesman coming to your door to sell you a faulty product - such criticism can often be worded in an apparently intelligent manner. But is it truthful?
[edit] Thank you!
For your work at Anti-racist mathematics. futurebird 20:47, 11 February 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Metamath
Thank you for your improvements to my somewhat loose English. I have been planning to write a new version of this page with more details. Anyway I don't know exactly when I will release it. -- fl —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 82.127.41.206 (talk) 11:55, 3 March 2007 (UTC).
[edit] Some Useful Presentation Material
 |
This user is interested in the Victorian period. |
 |
This user enjoys reading almost anything. |
 |
This user enjoys reading alternate history fiction. |
 |
This user enjoys jazz music. |
| Blue | This user enjoys blues music. |
 |
This user enjoys writing. |
| ^_~ | This user is a definite fan of Manga. |
| ~_~ | This user is a definite fan of Anime. |
 |
This user patrols the recent changes Old School Style. |
 |
This user would shoot Greedo first. |
 |
This user believes that a user's edit count does not necessarily reflect on the value of their contributions to Wikipedia. |
[edit] (line break)
[edit] Tag opinions
Please do not add unhelpful and non-constructive information to Wikipedia, as you did to Race and crime. Your edits could be considered vandalism, and have been reverted. If you would like to experiment, please use the sandbox. Thank you.
- This is in response to the fact that you placed over 80 banner templates throughout this article. Joie de Vivre 20:31, 19 March 2007 (UTC)
Please do not introduce any form of vandalism to the userpages of other users. Thank you.
- This is in response to the fact that you placed 18 of those banner tags on my Talk page. Joie de Vivre 20:31, 19 March 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Race and Crime Tag Remarks
It is clear to me that you have your own interpretations of the term vandalism. I have quoted the term before. Clearly, I felt that discussing such a complex issue required a high degree of analysis - and what better way to do this than to bring up the issues of each tag individually?
Again, it does appears that you have your own definitions of vandalism that are *self-serving* in the extreme (probably a reflection of the extreme position of the race and crime article). The tags were placed on the article in a way that would bring the reader to the attention of the various issues of the article edits. There will be more discussion of this in future, I'm sure.
Nevertheless, you are wrong to state that I vandalised your user page. I did not. I merely presented the self-same articles on the page that page you have *specifically designated as being the page upon which messages of that nature are left*. Of course, they took up a considerable amount of space - but no more than would be done on the article itself! If you do not like the idea of lengthy arguments being directed or left on your message or talk page - perhaps you should specify a length for those arguments that might tax your intellect so greatly?
MrASingh 14:05, 20 March 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Anti-bias mathematics practice deleted
I deleted this page, since it didn't look like it was trying to be an encyclopedia article. Friday (talk) 20:42, 3 April 2007 (UTC)
- Same goes for Standardised_Mathematics_Practice.. Not sure what you're trying to do here. Friday (talk) 20:46, 3 April 2007 (UTC)
ang:14 Winterfylleþ ar:14 أكتوبر an:14 d'otubre frp:14 octobro ast:14 d'ochobre bn:অক্টোবর ১৪ be:14 кастрычніка bpy:অক্টোবর ১৪ bs:14. oktobar br:14 Here bg:14 октомври ca:14 d'octubre cv:Юпа, 14 ceb:Oktubre 14 cs:14. říjen co:14 uttrovi cy:14 Hydref da:14. oktober de:14. Oktober et:14. oktoober el:14 Οκτωβρίου es:14 de octubre eo:14-a de oktobro eu:Urriaren 14 fo:14. oktober fr:14 octobre fy:14 oktober fur:14 di Otubar ga:14 Deireadh Fómhair gl:14 de outubro ko:10월 14일 hr:14. listopada io:14 di oktobro id:14 Oktober ia:14 de octobre is:14. október it:14 ottobre he:14 באוקטובר jv:14 Oktober ka:14 ოქტომბერი csb:14 rujana sw:14 Oktoba ku:14'ê kewçêrê la:14 Octobris lb:14. Oktober lt:Spalio 14 li:14 oktober lmo:14 10 hu:Október 14 mk:14 октомври ms:14 Oktober nl:14 oktober nds-nl:14 oktober new:अक्टोबर १४ ja:10月14日 nap:14 'e ottovre no:14. oktober nn:14. oktober nrm:14 Octobre nov:14 de oktobre oc:14 d'octobre nds:14. Oktober pl:14 października pt:14 de Outubro ksh:14. Oktoober ro:14 octombrie ru:14 октября war:Oktubre 14 se:Golggotmánu 14. sco:14 October sq:14 Tetor scn:14 di uttùviru simple:October 14 sk:14. október sl:14. oktober sr:14. октобар su:14 Oktober fi:14. lokakuuta sv:14 oktober tl:Oktubre 14 ta:அக்டோபர் 14 tt:14. Öktäber te:అక్టోబర్ 14 th:14 ตุลาคม vi:14 tháng 10 tr:14 Ekim uk:14 жовтня vec:14 de otobre wa:14 d' octôbe zh:10月14日
Categories: Wikipedians interested in history | Wikipedians interested in the Victorian period | Wikipedians who read alternate history fiction | Wikipedian writers | Wikipedians who like manga | Wikipedians interested in anime and manga | Wikipedians who play pen-and-paper games | Wikipedian recent changes patrollers | Wikipedians who like Star Wars | October
