Wikipedia:Press coverage
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Wikipedia in the media |
Wikipedia as a topic: |
In the press |
In academic studies |
In blogs |
In books |
In press releases |
In webcomics |
In comics |
On TV and radio |
Heaps of praise |
Wikipedia as a source: |
In academic studies |
In books |
In conference |
In court cases |
In the press |
In webcomics |
On TV and radio |
Elsewhere |
This page lists press coverage of Wikipedia that mentions or discusses Wikipedia as a project – that is, any aspect of Wikipedia overall, such as its structure, success, information, goals, history, or views on Wikipedia in general, and so on.
Articles that reference Wikipedia content but which do not discuss the project itself should be recorded at Wikipedia:Wikipedia as a press source. The template {{press}} may also be used to document mention of specific articles on their talk page. Great quotes from articles should be included in our Trophy box.
- IF THERE ARE ERRORS IN AN ARTICLE, please post the matter to the Wikimedia Communications Committee's talk page. This way, the Wikimedia Foundation can send an official letter to the editor, or request for a correction.
Contents |
[edit] Searching for discussion of Wikipedia online
The easiest way to search is to subscribe to a realtime Google Alert for "Wikipedia."
[edit] How to add cites to this page
If you add an article, please cite both the title and the source. Note that if you're listing an article from a traditional press wire service that ran in your local newspaper, it may not have the same title everywhere; be cautious about duplicates.
Please add your entry to the end of the page, using Template:Cite news. The template, with the most commonly used parameters, is:
- {{cite news |first= |last= |authorlink= |coauthors= |title= |url= |work= |publisher= |date= |accessdate=2007-04-03 }}
- "Relevant/representative quote here."
[edit] 2006 and earlier (Archived)
[edit] 2007
[edit] January
- January 2 2007
- Richter, Bob. "Express-News staffer resigns after plagiarism in column is discovered", San Antonio Express-News, 02 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-08.
-
- Columnist Jacqueline Gonzalez resigned after an investigation "found information, taken from Wikipedia, a free Internet encyclopedia, was published in the Watchdog column on Page 2B of the Metro section Dec. 25. The information that was not attributed concerned the origin of Dec. 25 as the birth date of Jesus Christ."
- Knight, Will. "Wikipedia links used to build smart reading lists", New Scientist magazine, 2 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-04.
- Reports on software developed by Alexander Wissner-Gross, a physics student at Harvard University, which builds reading lists based on the information held in the way Wikipedia articles interlink. Quote "Increasingly, a net user who wants to learn more about a subject will read its Wikipedia page," .... "However, for further depth in the subject, there has been no system for advising the user which other Wikipedia articles to read, and in which order."
- January 3 2007
- Krane, Jim. "Ooops: Wikipedia Blocks Posts From Qatar", Associated Press, 3 January 2007.
- "Our apologies to the people of Qatar," Gerard said on Wednesday. "It was a mistake. We won't do it again - unless somebody slips up, in which case it will be remedied quickly."
- January 4 2007
- Bambenek, John. "Wikipedia: Garbage in, Garbage out", MercatorNet, 4 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-04.
- General attack from a long list of what the author sees as Wikipedia's shortcomings. e.g. over 58% of Wikipedia articles are unsourced, stubs with no content, lists of other articles or simply garbage. 226 pages are dedicated to Pokemon. (The author's bio on Wikipedia had previously been deleted for not meeting the notability criteria; see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John C. A. Bambenek (3rd nomination).)
- January 6 2007
- Goldacre, Ben. "Doctored information on celebrity nutritionist", The Guardian, 6 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-06.
- Discusses the practice of controversial figures editing their own biographies on Wikipedia, or getting their "hip young PR agent" to edit them. It refers in particular to Patrick Holford, with whom Ben Goldacre has a dispute over his qualifications and approach. He refers to edits by User:Clarkeola on 22 December.
- anon. "Researchers Use Wikipedia To Make Computers Smarter", Physorg.com, 06 January, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-07.
-
- "Using Wikipedia, Technion researchers have developed a way to give computers knowledge of the world to help them “think smarter,” making common sense and broad-based connections between topics just as the human mind does. The new method will help computers filter e-mail spam, perform Web searches and even conduct intelligence gathering at more sophisticated levels than current programs."
- January 7 2007
- Griffiths, Martin. "Talking physics in the social Web", Physics World, January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-07.
-
- Summarizes some views on Wikipedia by physicists/scientists, including Nobel Laureate Philip Anderson ("I wouldn't dream of reading Wikipedia for physics. Nor would I trust it if I did.") Paper version (Physicsworld, Volume 20, Number 1, page 27) states "75% of respondents use Wikipedia for physics information. However, only 5% regularly contribute to the online encyclopedia." Mike Peel 11:37, 7 January 2007 (UTC)
- January 10 2007
- O'Brien, Erin. "Before the Court of Wikipedia", Cleveland Free Times, 10 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-10.
-
- "My Wikipedia article was deleted. I am not delusional. Even though the online reference tool bills itself as "the free encyclopedia anyone can edit," there must be some control over Wikipedia content or some jamoke with nothing better to do in Altoona, Pennsylvania would get his jollies by adding his very own special thoughts to pages referencing orgasm (you know what it is) or cleft of Venus (look it up for yourself)." O'Brien also notes claims in the articles John O'Brien (novelist) and Leaving Las Vegas which she calls false (these statements are also contained in the corresponding IMDb entries) and says "I tried to edit out the erroneous statements on both sites, but some Kiss-the-Hem-of-my-Purple-Robe Wikipedian Lord apparently usurped my efforts." However, the edit histories of both articles show no such edits.
- January 11 2007
- McDonough, Ted. "Utah’s Wiki Wars", Salt Lake City Weekly, 11 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-15.
-
- Describes some of the disputes concerning Utah-related articles. Prominently mentions EnergySolutions Arena and Larry H. Miller as examples where IP addresses representing the subjects themselves edited articles. The former even spawned another story on how EnergySolutions allegedly guards its image. See Fahys, Judy. "Arena spurs edit meltdown on Wikipedia site", Salt Lake Tribune, 12 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-15.
- January 14 2007
- Hinson, Mark. "Let county criticisms commence", Tallahassee Democrat, 14 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-14.
-
- Author describes his dismay at finding Jackson County, Florida had been vandalised and then humorously describes how he responds by vandalising other county entries for his amusement. This vandalism seems hypothetical as Bay County, Florida, Calhoun County, Florida, and Liberty County, Florida show no sign of the changes he describes.
- January 15 2007
- Janani, Gopalakrishnan. "Look Up (To) Wikipedia", Linux For You (Subscription), January 1, 2007, pp. 35-37. Retrieved on 2007-01-21.
-
- "We trace the genesis and progression of this repository of knowledge wealth, popularly known as Wikipedia."
- Dawson, Joan M.. "Where Is the Love in Wikipedia?", OhmyNews International, 15 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-15.
-
- This piece of citizen journalism is subtitled "Online encyclopedia riddled with bias in matters of the heart." The author finds the marriage article "offensive" because "as I clicked on the links ... I was never taken to love" and "I had to type [the word 'love'] into Wikipedia's search engine to find it" (in fact there is a prominent link to love in the "close relationships" sidebar of the marriage article). She then comes across a series of articles which she finds "eye-opening and jaw-dropping" including men's movement, allegations of domestic violence, blame, emotional abuse, hysterics, penis envy, annulment, divorce, and so on.
- Smith, Wes. "He's the "God-King," but you can call him Jimbo", Orlando Sentinel, reprinted in Seattle Times, 15 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-15.
-
- Profiles Jimmy Wales and discusses rumors that he may move from Florida to Silicon Valley.
- January 21 2007
- "Marked for Deletion", Weekend America, January 20, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-21.
-
- The American Public Media radio show interviewed Wikipedians Troy Diggs and Jon Radoff about the Articles for deletion discussion for the article on Wichita news anchor Susan Peters, who also appeared on the program.
- January 22 2007
- Groening, Tom. "Educators warn students: Be wary of Web", Bangor Daily News, January 22, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-22.
-
- Article about students' difficulties in adequately assessing information found on the Internet when doing research mentions, in passing, "the widely publicized errors found on Wikipedia.com." Not only is the wrong domain used, a commenter notes the article itself inaccurately describes a state computer initiative.
- Johnson, Bobbie. "Wikipedia adopts " "", Guardian, January 22, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-22.
- January 24 2007
- Bergstein, Brian. "Microsoft offers cash for Wikipedia edit", USA Today, January 24, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-24.
-
- In this widely reprinted Associated Press report, Microsoft is accused of offering payment to blogger and "technical standards aficianado" Rick Jelliffe in order to "correct" Wikipedia entries, revealed in Jelliffe's original blog posting (but not this report) to be ODF and OOXML. "Microsoft acknowledged it had approached the writer and offered to pay him for the time it would take to correct what the company was sure were inaccuracies in Wikipedia articles on an open-source document standard and a rival format put forward by Microsoft." Microsoft and Jelliffe "had not determined a price and no money had changed hands — but they had agreed that the company would not be allowed to review his writing before submission". Jimbo Wales is quoted as being "very disappointed to hear that Microsoft was taking that approach".
- January 25 2007
- Bergstein, Brian. "Idea of Paid Entries Roils Wikipedia", Earthlink News (Associated Press), 24 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-25.
-
- This article focuses on the interaction between Wales and Gregory Kohs, founder of MyWikiBiz with emphasis on the Wikipedia:Reward board: "When a blogger revealed this week that Microsoft Corp. wanted to pay him to fix purported inaccuracies in technical articles on Wikipedia, the software company endured online slams and a rebuke from the Web encyclopedia's founder for behaving unethically."
- January 26 2007
- Jaschik, Scott. "A Stand against Wikipedia", Inside Higher Ed, 26 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-26.
-
- Article on restrictions by the Middlebury College history department on students citing Wikipedia. Many comments by educators on the uses and reliability of the site.
- Naughton, John. "The Networker: Wikipedia, you are the strongest link", The Guardian, January 26, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-26.
-
- The 'No Follow' issue and the use of Wikipedia articles as a footnote "to avoid a digression from their discourse" is discussed. Is "Wikipedia now in the same league" as Google as a web source?
- Grim, Ryan. "Federal Agency Cleans Up Its Own Wikipedia Entry", The Politico, January 26, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-26.
-
- More detailed account of NIDA edit war.
- Elsworth, Catherine. "Microsoft under fire in Wiki edit war", The Daily Telegraph, 26 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-26.
-
- Reports on the dispute over Microsoft's editing, containing some details from the Associated Press and some additional reporting. It is angled as a debate raging on the internet: "Some are calling it "Wikigate 07". Others see it as a storm on a mouse mat." The piece observes "The software giant has been accused of breaching the spirit of Wikipedia" and recants previous examples of deliberate conflict of interest editing.
- "YouTube, Wikipedia storm into 2006 top brand ranking", USA Today (Reuters), 26 January 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-26.
-
- In an annual survey of "3,625 branding professionals and students", brandchannel.com asked "Which brand had the most impact on our lives in 2006?". Wikipedia came fourth, behind Google, Apple and YouTube. Starbucks was fifth.
- January 27 2007
- Pareene, Alex. "National Institute of Health Division Bravely Edits Own Wikpedia Entry", Wonkette, January 25, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-27.
-
- Discusses efforts by National Institute on Drug Abuse employees to edit the article to make it favorable to the agency and ensuing edit war. Jokingly encourages readers to get back at NIDA by vandalizing and adding made-up negative information about NIDA.
- January 28 2007
- "Making Connections a World Away", Peace Journalism, January 28, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-28.
-
- Focuses on the multilingual nature of Wikipedia. Articles "are available in languages from Esperanto to Hawaiian to Navajo, gaining considerable ground on English, German, French, Polish, and Japanese, which remain the most prevalent languages on Wikipedia. 'It started in an organic, ad hoc way,' says Samuel Klein, one of hundreds of administrators who monitor multilingual content for Wiki sites. 'New people who are multilingual see the community exists, they find the existing pages, and they join in,' Klein adds."
- January 29 2007
- Cohen, Noam. "Courts Turn to Wikipedia, but Selectively", New York Times, January 29, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-29.
-
- "A simple search of published court decisions shows that Wikipedia is frequently cited by judges around the country, involving serious issues and the bizarre". The writer doesn't appear to know that one can create links to specific page versions in the history to make a stable reference.
- January 31 2007
- "comScore Networks Releases Top Web Properties Worldwide for December; Reviews Biggest Gainers for 2006", Yahoo! Finance (PR Newswire), January 31, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-01-31.
-
- "comScore Networks, a leader in measuring the digital age, today reported the top worldwide Web properties for December, ranked by unique visitors." Number six on the list with 164,675,000 "unique visitors" is "Wikipedia sites", behind "Microsoft sites", "Google sites", "Yahoo! sites", "Time Warner network" and "eBay". Only "unique visitors" over 15 years of age were counted, and the list "[e]xcludes traffic from public computers such as Internet cafes and access from mobile phones or PDAs". These numbers presumably come from comScore's "massive, global cross-section of more than 2 million consumers who have given comScore permission to confidentially capture their browsing and transaction behaviour". How the "Web properties" were defined (for example, whether YouTube counts as a "Google site") is not explained.
[edit] February
- February 1 2007
- Getz, Arlene. "In Search of an Online Utopia", Newsweek, 1 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-02.
- Interview with Jimbo Wales after Davos. Jimbo is reported as stating, "I talked to Bill Gates there—the first time I’ve met him. Lately there’ve been reports in the media about Microsoft versus Wikipedia, which we think is really silly because we’re not battling Microsoft. It was a very brief chat—he said he liked Wikipedia."
- February 3 2007
- Marks, Paul. "Interview:Knowledge to the people", New Scientist, 3 February 2007. (in English)
- He's inundated with offers, people turn out to see him, and journalists dog his every move: Jimmy "Jimbo" Wales has all the hallmarks of a rock star. Except he isn't one. He's the man who founded Wikipedia, the vast online encyclopedia used by millions every day. Wikipedia employs just five full-timers, yet it already has 1.5 million articles written by users in a growing number of the world's languages. A diehard core of 400 online volunteers help to keep vendettas, vandals and crazies at bay. So what gave Wales his big idea? Can the open Wikipedia ethic survive in a world dominated by corporations? Paul Marks caught up with him recently after he gave a lecture to a packed hall at the London School of Economics.
- February 7 2007
- Torbati, June. "Profs question students' Wikipedia dependency", Yale Daily News, 7 February 2007. (in English)
- "A few Yale professors are adamantly opposed to the use of Wikipedia for academic work, though many of their peers said it has not caused problems at Yale and students said they continue to rely on the encyclopedia for help with their schoolwork." Also mentions a fake entry for emysphilia created by a Yale student.
- Sutherland, John. "Something Wiki this way comes", The Guardian, 7 February 2007. (in English)
- "Wikipedia is addictively usable. I've just used it, for example, to research Wikipedia. It combines new, interactive, information technologies with an extraordinary economy of effort and speed of delivery. It's run, incredibly, by five people for pennies, and offers itself to the logged-in millions for free." Mentions the Middlebury College incident; praises the Robert Louis Stevenson article but criticizes the John Sutherland entry.
- February 9 2007
- Eriksson, Anja. "Wikipedia nära krascha av nyheten", Expressen, 2007-02-09. (in Swedish)
- Wikipedia was close to crash when people went there to read about the death of Anna-Nicole Smith.*Siegel, Robert. "How Wikipedia Breaks News, and Adjusts to It", NPR All Things Considered, 9 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-10.
- Audio interview of Jimmy Wales about updating of the Anna Nicole Smith article upon her death.
- February 11 2007
- Farrell, Nick. "Wikipedia is running out of cash", The Inquirer, 11 February 2007. (in English)
- "Florence Devouard, chairwoman of the Wikimedia Foundation, told the Lift07 conference that the outfit might join the Everywhere Girl and disappear from the Interweb. ... Sandy Ordonez claimed that Devouard's comment was taken out of context and Wikipedia will not be closing any time soon."
- Brumont, Laure. "'Madame Wikipedia' runs web giant from village HQ", Middle East Times reporting Agence France-Presse, 11 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-11.
- Profile of Florence Devouard, new chair of the board of Wikipedia. " "What got me hooked was the idea of being able to write articles that left nothing out," she explained from her home in Malintrat, a village of 900 souls outside the city of Clermont Ferrand - a region better known for its extinct volcanoes and pure spring water than its Internet start-ups."
- February 14 2007
- Gralla, Preston. "U.S. senator: It's time to ban Wikipedia in schools, libraries", Computerworld, 2007-2-14. Retrieved on 2007-02-16.
- "Here's the newest from Sen. Ted Stevens, the man who described the Internet as a series of tubes: It's time for the federal government to ban access to Wikipedia, MySpace, and social networking sites from schools and libraries." Stevens is sponsoring legislation to require schools to ban students from using interactive web sites. It is not clear whether the proposed law would actually ban Wikipedia.
- February 15 2007
- Cohen, Patricia. "Supercharged With All The Answers", New York Times, 15 February 2007. (in English)
- "It’s like the classic scene in Woody Allen’s 1977 film Annie Hall, when Alvy Singer imagines how he would like to reply to the know-it-all standing behind him in line for a movie and pontificating about Marshall McLuhan. Now, instead of pulling McLuhan out from behind a poster to scold, 'You know nothing of my work,' Alvy could just pull out his BlackBerry and shove the Wikipedia entry in the guy’s face." Relates how an HBO executive used Wikipedia's article on the immaculate conception to settle a dispute in a restaurant.
- Fox, Justin. "Getting Rich off Those Who Work for Free", TIME magazine, TIME Inc., Feb. 15, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-20.
- That I even know of Kropotkin comes courtesy of the Wikipedia entry for the "gift economy," the current term of art for this altruistic approach. Wikipedia is, of course, a prime example of the gift economy at work. Argue about its inaccuracies all you want, but the volunteer-authored online encyclopedia is on its way to becoming (if it isn't already) the world's dominant reference resource.
- February 16 2007
- Raivio, Jarmo. "Wikipedia juhlii", Suomen Kuvalehti, 16 February 2007. (in Finnish)
- The Finnish edition of Wikipedia reached one hundred thousand articles on Sunday, 11 February.
- February 20 2007
- "Readers' Q & A with Wikipedia founder", New Scientist, 20 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-21.
- "Jimmy Wales has responded to the best reader questions sparked by our exclusive original interview."
- February 21 2007
- Cohen, Noam. "A History Department Bans Citing Wikipedia as a Research Source", New York Times, 21 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-21.
- "When half a dozen students in Neil Waters’s Japanese history class at Middlebury College asserted on exams that the Jesuits supported the Shimabara Rebellion in 17th-century Japan, he knew something was wrong[...] The obscure, though incorrect, information was from Wikipedia, the collaborative online encyclopedia, and the students had picked it up cramming for his exam."
- February 22 2007
- Danner, Patrick. "Golfer Zoeller sues law firm for Wikipedia posting", Miami Herald, 22 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-22.
- "Pro golfer Fuzzy Zoeller is teed off over what he calls defamatory statements about him on Wikipedia.
- "But instead of suing the popular online reference site, Zoeller is taking a swing at a Miami company. In a lawsuit filed last week in Miami-Dade Circuit Court, Zoeller -- suing under the name John Doe -- alleged the statements were posted from a computer belonging to Josef Silny & Associates."
- Morris, Maggie. "Expert: Wikipedia won't go away, so learn how to use it", Physorg.com, 22 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-23.
- Comments by Sorin A. Matei, assistant professor in the Department of Communication at Purdue University."Matei recommends Wikipedia be used as a search engine that acts as a springboard to other resources and that it never be cited as a primary source of information."
- Adams, David. "Fast facts found online", The Age, 22 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-22.
- David Adams talks to four Australians who have helped to build the collaborative online giant that is Wikipedia: Nick Carson, Enoch Lau, Angela Beesley and Tim Starling, as well as Jimmy Wales.
- February 24 2007
- Okoben, Janet. "Oberlin College history class told to use controversial site", Cleveland Plain Dealer, 24 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-27.
-
Oberlin College students in Elizabeth Colantoni's class on ancient Rome are not just encouraged, but required, to use the controversial online encyclopedia Wikipedia for their research this semester. That seems contrary to the backlash against the Web site, which uses entries written by users of the site regardless of the writer's expertise on the matter. And that's Colantoni's point.[1]
- February 25 2007
- Rushfield, Richard. "Web Scout: The real-time encyclopedia", Los Angeles Times, 25 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-25.
- Article about the rapid response of editors and vandalism patrollers to news of Anna Nichole Smith's death.
- Kirkpatrick, David. "Wikipedia's next steps", CNNMoney.com, 23 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-25.
- Jimmy Wales is interviewed by Fortune's David Kirkpatrick about Wikipedia and his commercial project Wikia, and why the world needs an open source search engine.
- February 26 2007
- Moss-Coane, Marty. "Radio Times", WHYY-FM, 26 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-26.
-
Why one of the internet's most popular internet encyclopedias is also considered unreliable. We'll talk with NEIL WATERS a professor at Middlebury College, who discovered an obscure but incorrect fact on his students' exams. It turns out they all got it from the same source Wikipedia. Then we'll hear from VIBIANA BOWMAN a librarian at Rutgers University in Camden, New Jersey about how Wikipedia and the internet in general is changing how we get information and we must adopt new standards for vetting it. Bowman is also author of The Plagiarism Plague in which she argues that the internet has made plagiarism an even bigger problem.
First broadcast 26 February 2007 11:00 am UTC-5, Podcast
- February 27 2007
- Noah, Timothy. "Rescued by Wikipedia", Slate, 26 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-27.
- Also Washington Post 2007-02-25 and The China Post,2007-03-04.
-
- Timothy Noah makes several criticisms of Wikipedia's Notability policy after his own entry was nominated for deletion. "Wikipedia's stubborn enforcement of its notability standard suggests that Veblen was right. We limit entry to the club not because we need to, but because we want to."
-
Is Wikipedia's ticket to "notability" the writing of one published article about … Wikipedia?
- February 28 2007
- Kiss, Jemima. "Jimmy Wales and that Bono email", The Guardian (Organ Grinder blog), 28 February 2007. Retrieved on 2007-02-28.
-
Wikipedia is viewed seven billion times a month and could've made a fortune through adverts. But that just wouldn't be right. Wikipedia is built on the hard work of a core of volunteers and contributions from, well, all of us - so the dynamic of the whole thing just wouldn't work if someone was buying Ferraris off the back of that.
[edit] March
[edit] Essjay controversy
- See also Essjay controversy
- "EDITORS’ NOTE", New Yorker, nd. Retrieved on 2007-03-01.
- "The July 31, 2006, piece on Wikipedia, “Know It All,” by Stacy Schiff, contained an interview with a Wikipedia site administrator and contributor called Essjay [...] He was described in the piece as “a tenured professor of religion at a private university” with “a Ph.D. in theology and a degree in canon law.” [...] Essjay now says that his real name is Ryan Jordan, that he is twenty-four and holds no advanced degrees, and that he has never taught."
- February 28 2007
- Lutter, David A.. "Wikipedia Source For 'New Yorker' A Fraud", WebProNews, February 28, 2007.
- Bercovici, Jeff. "Ode to Wikipedia Riddled with Errors", Radar Magazine, February 28, 2007.
- March 1 2007
- Kane, Margaret. "Wikipedia 101: Check your sources", CNET News. Retrieved on 2007-03-02.
- Ingram, Mathew. "The Wikipedia Admin Brouhaha", WebProNews, March 1, 2007.
- Sadofsky, Jason S (01 March 2007). Wikipedia: J.S. on Essjay. ASCII. Retrieved on 2007-03-02.
- March 2 2007
- Read, Brock. "Essjay, the Ersatz Academic", The Chronicle of Higher Education, March 2, 2007.
- Utter, David A. (2 March 2007). Wikipedia Source For 'New Yorker' A Fraud. WebProNews. Retrieved on 2007-03-02.
- Thomas, Brett (2 March 2007). Wikipedia manager lied about background. bit.tech.net. Retrieved on 2007-03-02.
- March 5 2007
- Mitch Ratcliffe. "Wikipedia: Why does Essjay need to “protect himself”?", ZD Net. Retrieved on 2007-03-05.
- March 6 2007
- "Fake professor in Wikipedia storm", BBC News, BBC, 2007-03-06. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- "Internet site Wikipedia has been hit by controversy after the disclosure that a prominent editor had assumed a false identity complete with fake PhD. The editor, known as Essjay, had described himself as a professor of religion at a private university."
- Dan Blacharski. "Blog Insights: Wikipedia's great fraud", ITworld.com. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Stephen Foley. "Wikipedia hit by identity crisis as student admits posing as professor", World news, Belfast Telegraph. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- "Blog Insights: Wikipedia's great fraud", Editors, Foreign Policy. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Orlowski, Andrew. "Farewell, Wikipedia?", The Register, March 6, 2007.
- "Key Wikipedia 'editor' unmasked as fraud", Irish Independent. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Elsworth, Catherine. "Fake Wikipedia prof altered 20,000 entries", The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Cherian, Jacob. "Controversy Emanates Over Fake Editor On Wikipedia", All Headline News. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Staff. "Bogus professor resigns as Wiki editor", United Press International. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Foley, Stephen. "Wikipedia ‘Prof’ Is A Fraudster", The Statesman. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Cohen, Noam. "Wikipedia ire turns against ex-editor", International Herald Tribune. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Staff. "Wikipedia editor resigns after credentials exposed as bogus", Associated Press. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Goldman, Russell. "Wikiscandal: A Prominent Editor at the Popular Online Encyclopedia Is a Fraud", ABC News. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Cherian, Jacob. "Controversy emanates over fake editor on Wikipedia", BizReport, March 6, 2007.
- Withers, Stephen. "Bogus professor quits Wikipedia", iTwire, Australia, March 6, 2007.
- Wolfson, Andrew. "Wikipedia editor who posed as professor is Ky. dropout", The Louisville Courier-Journal, March 6, 2007.
- Goldman, Russell. "A prominent editor at Wikipedia might not be what he says", 7 Online, March 6, 2007.
- March 7 2007
- Foley, Stephen. "Wikipedia hit by identity crisis as student admits posing as professor", The Independent, 2007-03-06. Retrieved on 2007-03-07.
- "Wikipedia is facing one of its biggest crises after a twentysomething student from Kentucky posed as a professor of religious studies and made more than 20,000 alterations to controversial topics on the online encyclopedia."
- Cohen, Noam. "A Contributor to Wikipedia Has His Fictional Side", The New York Times, 2007-03-05. Retrieved on 2007-03-05.
- Doran, James. "Wikipedia Editor Out After False Credentials Revealed", Fox News, 2007-03-06. Retrieved on 2007-03-07.
- Doran, James. "Wikipedia chief promises change after 'expert' exposed as fraud", The Times, 2007-03-06. Retrieved on 2007-03-07.
- "Wikipedia, the controversial online encyclopedia, is planning to ask its army of faceless Internet editors — known as Wikipedians — to verify their credentials after one of the most prolific of their number was exposed as a fraud."
- Elsworth, Catherine. "Wikipedia professor is 24-year-old college dropout", The Daily Telegraph, 2007-03-07. Retrieved on 2007-03-07.
- "Wikipedia, the online encyclopaedia, has been plunged into controversy after one of its most prolific contributors and editors, a professor with degrees in theology and canon law, was exposed as a 24-year-old college drop-out."
- EDITORIAL. "The net's limits", The Daily Telegraph, 2007-03-07. Retrieved on 2007-03-07.
- "...As a non-profit-making organisation the parent company, Wikimedia, trusts its contributors and editors. But a mischievous 24-year-old student has abused that trust by claiming to be a professor and arbitrated disputes about the validity of information on the website. It may be depressing that such abuse has occurred, but it is hardly surprising."
- Elsworth, Catherine. "Fake Wikipedia prof altered 20,000 entries", Telegraph.co.uk, March 7, 2007.
- Staff. "Wikipedia's 'bogus' editor ousted", Freelance UK, March 7, 2007.
- March 9 2007
- Williams, Martyn. "Wikipedia founder speaks out on the 'Essjay' brouhaha", Computer World, March 9, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-12.
- March 12 2007
- Cohen, Noam. "After False Claim, Wikipedia to Check Degrees", The New York Times, March 12, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-12.
[edit] Other March news
- Ball, Philip. "The more, the Wikier", nature.com, 2007-02-27. Retrieved on 2007-03-02.
- "Three groups of researchers claim to have untangled the process by which many Wikipedia entries achieve their impressive accuracy. They say that the best articles are those that are highly edited by many different contributors." and
-
- "In effect, the Wiki community has mutated since 2001 from an oligarchy to a democracy. The percentage of edits made by the Wikipedia 'élite' of administrators increased steadily up to 2004, when it reached around 50%. But since then it has steadily declined, and is now just 10% (and falling)."
- March 2 2007
- Dedman, Bill. "Reading Hillary Rodham's Hidden Thesis", MSNBC.com, March 2, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-17.
- MSNBC.com reported that Hillary Rodham Clinton had been incorrectly listed for 20 months in her Wikipedia biography as valedictorian of her class of 1969 at Wellesley College. (Hillary Rodham was not the valedictorian, though she did speak at commencement, giving rise to the inaccuracy.) The MSNBC article included a link to the Wikipedia edit, in which user LukeTH added the incorrect information on July 9, 2005. After the MSNBC report, the inaccurate information was removed the same day, with this edit. Between the two edits, the wrong information had stayed in the Clinton article while it was edited more than 4,800 times over the 20 months.
- Johnson, Bobbie. "Conservapedia - the US religious right's answer to Wikipedia" (Requires free registration), Guardian Unlimited, 2007-03-02. Retrieved on 2007-03-02.
- Also: Sydney Morning Herald
- "It has been attacked many times in its short life, most notably by a former aide to Robert F Kennedy and the editor of Encyclopaedia Britannica. But now the online reference site Wikipedia has a new foe: evangelical Christians."
- Kleeman, Jenny. "You couldn’t make it up", TimesOnline, 2007-03-02. Retrieved on 2007-03-02.
- Interviews with three Wikipedia editors, Charles Matthews a 52-year-old former Cambridge academic, Sarah a 17-year-old student and Angela Beesley of the Wikimedia Foundation. "But who are we actually relying on when we use Wikipedia? Little is known about the small army of regular volunteers who dedicate themselves to editing the site. I am here because I want to find out who they are — and why they do it. "
- The Kleeman article is followed by a note entitled "The fact it, it's rubbish" signed by Richard Dixon, "Chief Revise Editor" of The Times. It includes these thoughts: "My default position is that every article on Wikipedia is rubbish. When, for example, I need medical information, I go to a reputable medical site, such as the British Medical Journal or The New England Journal of Medicine."
- March 5 2007
- "Wikipedia founder to visit Australia", The Age, 2007-03-05. Retrieved on 2007-03-05.
- The founder of online encyclopedia Wikipedia, Jimmy Wales, will visit Australia next month as a key speaker at a series of seminars on the future of knowledge.
- March 6 2007
- "Students assessed with Wikipedia", BBC News, BBC, 2007-03-06. Retrieved on 2007-03-06.
- Reports on postgrad students editing Wikipedia as part of a University of East Anglia course. Politics lecturer, Nicola Pratt, says using Wikipedia can develop students' research skills. "The Wikipedia-based Middle East course counts for an eighth of the students' MA assessment." .. "They're assessed on their ability to improve the quality and balance of the article and they demonstrate they have done that through additional reading around the topic for that week.
- March 7 2007
- MacLeod, Donald. "Students marked on writing in Wikipedia", The Guardian, 2007-03-07. Retrieved on 2007-03-07.
- "Wikipedia - banned by some academics as a source for student essays - has been made compulsory reading (and writing) for a new course at the University of East Anglia."
- March 10 2007
- "Online encyclopedias - Fact or fiction?", The Economist, 2007-03-10. Retrieved on 2007-03-12.
- "So how useful is Wikipedia? Entries on uncontentious issues—logarithms, for example—are often admirable. The quality of writing is often a good guide to an entry’s usefulness: inelegant or ranting prose usually reflects muddled thoughts and incomplete information. A regular user soon gets a feel for what to trust.
Those on contentious issues are useful in a different way. The information may be only roughly balanced. But the furiously contested entries on, say, Armenian genocide or Scientology, and their attached discussion pages, do give the reader an useful idea about the contours of the arguments, and the conflicting sources and approaches."
- "So how useful is Wikipedia? Entries on uncontentious issues—logarithms, for example—are often admirable. The quality of writing is often a good guide to an entry’s usefulness: inelegant or ranting prose usually reflects muddled thoughts and incomplete information. A regular user soon gets a feel for what to trust.
- March 11 2007
- Kamiya, Setsuko. "Power to the Wikipeople", The Japan Times Online, The Japan Times Inc.. Retrieved on 2007-03-11. (in English)
- An interview with Jimmy Wales, "Why do you think the rate of growth has slowed on the Japanese Wikipedia compared to other languages?
-
- I don't really know. That's what I'm here to find out. Maybe it needs more promotion. But it's very difficult to say. Some of it is the Japanese Wikipedia used to be larger than the French, and there were twice as many editors working in the French Wikipedia. So we used to joke that "there's more French but the Japanese work harder." (Laughs):
- "Wikipedia - How Accurate Is The Online Encyclopedia?", London Evening Standard, 2007-03-11. Retrieved on 2007-03-11.
-
- Asks four celebrities to assess the accuracy of their own Wikipedia articles. Peter Hitchens - " But in the end, I'm in favour of Wikipedia. It seems to me that most users and contributors are trying to reach the truth in a reasonable manner. And that can never be a bad thing." Edwina Currie - "So don't take this 'encyclopedia' seriously. It's less accurate than most gossip columns." Craig Murray - "But the result is fair and authoritative - I am proud of my entry." Peter Tatchell - "My advice? Use Wikipedia as a resource, but check controversial claims with other sources. As my entry shows, Wikipedia is open to abuse." The Standard states the incorrect information about Essjay was publicized "when a magazine published an article on Wikipedia two weeks ago" -- Stacy Schiff's New Yorker article was actually published in July 2006. The article in Evening Standard is also mirrored here.
- March 13 2007
- Beam, Alex. "Meanwhile: My sticky Wiki", International Herald Tribune, March 13, 2007.
- Letter to Editor: McClellan, Joel. "Open source approach", International Herald Tribune, March 16, 2007.
-
- Journalist Alex Beam on how he got his Wikipedia entry improved. "...a friend slipped me a magic phone number that rang in the office of Stanford Law professor Lawrence Lessig, the Learned Hand of the Internet bar. His helpful assistant relayed my complaint to Wales, who sits on a board with Lessig. Soon afterward, the offending paragraphs were removed."
- March 15 2007
- ""Wiki" wins place in dictionary", Yahoo/Reuters, March 15, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-15.
- Wiki gains a place in the OED.- "If you think "wiki" doesn't sound like English, you are right. But it's English now. This word born on the Pacific Island of Hawaii finally got an entry into the latest edition of the online Oxford English Dictionary along with 287 other new words." ... "The most famous example is the popular Internet encyclopaedia Wikipedia."
- March 16 2007
- Kennedy, Kelli. "Wikipedia Falsely Reports Sinbad's Death", Wire, Associated Press, March 16, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-16.
- "Actor-comedian Sinbad had the last laugh after his Wikipedia entry announced he was dead, the performer said Thursday."
- Weingarten, Gene. "A wickedly fun test of Wikipedia", The News & Observer, Mar 16, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-19.
- Gene Weingarten on how he tested Wikipedia by editing false information into his own entry to see if it was spotted. It was removed 3 days later by User:Subwayguy.
- March 20 2007
- Willinsky, John. "What open access research can do for Wikipedia", First Monday, March 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-20.
- "This study examines the degree to which Wikipedia entries cite or reference research and scholarship, and whether that research and scholarship is generally available to readers. Working on the assumption that where Wikipedia provides links to research and scholarship that readers can readily consult, it increases the authority, reliability, and educational quality of this popular encyclopedia, this study examines Wikipedia’s use of open access research and scholarship, that is, peer-reviewed journal articles that have been made freely available online. "
- March 21 2007
- Rauchway, Eric. "Wikipedia is good for academia", The New Republic, March 21 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-25.
- 'People with money, reputation, and control over public information have historically used their power to retain control over the means of producing knowledge[...] Professors can no more undo the public sphere of the Internet than the embattled experts of the early modern era could undo the coffee houses[...] Articles need to cite "reliable sources," which are those that use "process and approval between document creation and publication." In other words, academic work: Wikipedia is on our side..'
- March 22 2007
Claburn, Thomas. "Wikipedia Becomes Intelligence Tool And Target For Jihadists", InformationWeek, March 22 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-26.
-
- On how both state and other interests might want to influence the slant of articles on Wikipedia. "Wikipedia, like Switzerland, wants to be neutral. But the new bankers of the Net's knowledge face foes invested in partisan points of view. "
- March 23 2007
- Scott, Mike. "The day I downloaded myself", The Guardian, Mar 23, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-23.
- "When Mike Scott of the Waterboys looked at the Wikipedia entry on himself, he got quite a shock". A very favorable piece, after being reverted Mike engaged in dialogue with other editors, provided citations which led to some factural corrections. Mike thought his article was better than most other bios he had read.
- Zetter, Kim. "Wikipedia Shakeup: Resignations", Wired News, March 23, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-24.
- "Two top employees of the Wikimedia Foundation have resigned." About Danny Wool and Brad Patrick.
- March 25 2007
- Kleeman, Jenny. "Wiki wars", The Observer, 25 March, 2007. Retrieved on 2007-03-25.
- A piece that concentrates on efforts to stop vandalism. "Theresa Knott is one such devoted Wikipedian. A member since 2001, she visits the site daily, often editing at 5.30am before she leaves for work as a London primary school teacher. Her efforts have been rewarded with regular abuse from vandals and kudos from her Wikipedia peers, who elected her to the position of administrator in 2003."
- March 26 2007
- Associated Press. "Two who were there dispute founding of online encyclopedia", Boston Globe, 2007-03-26. Retrieved on 2007-03-26.
- A short piece about whether or not Larry Sanger was cofounder of Wikipedia, including a quote from Jimbo.
- Associated Press. "Wikipedia competitor seeks to cut out errors", Boston Globe, 2007-03-26. Retrieved on 2007-03-26.}
- Primarily about Citizendium launching, discusson as a fork of and competitor to Wikipedia.
- March 27 2007
- Associated Press. "Citizendium Head's Role in Founding Wikipedia Unclear", Fox News, 2007-03-27. Retrieved on 2007-03-27.
- Reports on the continuing dispute between Wales and Sanger over the significance of Sangers part in the founding of Wikipedia. "The Wikipedia entry on Wales also holds that Sanger played a sizable role, even giving Wikipedia its name. Without a doubt, Sanger was an early community leader on Wikipedia. But Wales insists that Sanger was a subordinate employee of his, and by that measure, 20 other people would deserve co-founder status."
- Moses, Asher. "Founder defends evolving Wikipedia", The Sydney Morning Herald, 2007-03-27. Retrieved on 2007-03-27.
- One of many to fall victim to false Wikipedia entries is the former governor-general of Australia, Peter Hollingworth. Mr Hollingworth called in to the ABC radio program Australia Talks last week, as it was interviewing Mr Wales.
- March 28 2007
- Kleeman, Jenny. "Wikipedia braces itself for April Fools' Day", The Guardian newspaper, 2007-03-28. Retrieved on 2007-03-30.
- On the problems faced by Wikipedia on April Fools Day. "Spare a thought for Wikipedia editors this Sunday. While most of us are leafing through the newspapers and enjoying a long lunch, they will be stationed in front of their computers, bracing themselves to defend the site against the annual onslaught of April Fools' hoaxes."
[edit] April
- Please use Wikipedia Template:Cite news for entries here.